HomeView
Image source:
RANKING
2
Rank 2 out of 2 Summarized in this category Rankings based on: • Pros-to-cons ratio • Number of reviews • Category average

Apple

HomeView

price N/A

i
All prices are estimates and may vary from actual prices.

520 Pros

61%
43 reviews (6h 31m)

335 Cons

68%

200 vs 95

Features & Functionality

60%

74 vs 50

Design & Build Quality

22%

24 vs 85

Value for Money

74%

43 vs 15

Sound Quality

76%

64 vs 20

Smart Assistant Performance

Reviewer verdict

Pros Cons Index analysed 43 YouTube video reviews of the Apple HomeView: it earns an Index score of 3.4/5, ranking #2 among Smart Displays. Reviewers most often praise its features & functionality, design & build quality, smart assistant performance, while the most common criticisms concern features & functionality, value for money.

Pros: A well-made, privacy-minded Apple smart home hub that blends a polished 7″ display, strong HomeKit integration, and good speakers for $299.

HomeView is praised as a polished, Apple-style smart home centerpiece: a compact 7-inch Liquid Retina display on a solid metal body with an optional speaker base, Center Stage 12MP camera, and A18 performance. Reviewers highlight seamless HomeKit and Matter/Thread hub integration, multi-user face recognition (up to six people) with privacy gating, useful kitchen features (recipe step-throughs, timers), Handoff/AirPlay and FaceTime support, and customizable watch-face like screens. Its speakers, configurable wall or tabletop form factors, and deep Apple ecosystem ties make it a convenient, familiar control surface and music hub at a competitive $299 entry price for Apple customers.

Cons: First-gen limitations, limited app support, and pricing/packaging choices undercut its value for many buyers.

Common criticisms center on limited added value versus phones/iPads and rival smart displays: HomeView lacks a general App Store and native third-party apps, has a small 7″ square LCD (60Hz) with thick bezels, and the wall and tabletop versions share the same $299 price despite the wall unit omitting the woofer and included power/ mount. Reviewers also noted reliance on a recent iPhone for personal Siri features, extra cost and complexity for wall mounting, uncertain Face-recognition/security limits (not full Face ID), and regional/feature rollouts that make some capabilities feel incomplete at launch.

Analysis based on 43 YouTube reviews (6h 31m of video) with 520 pros and 335 cons extracted.

Pros (520)

Features & Functionality (200)
  • Camera can be used as a mirror feature when wall-mounted — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Smooth, elegant operating system consistent with Apple design — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Fills a hole in Apple's smart home ecosystem, offering an Apple-branded hub/dashboard to compete with Google/Amazon — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Includes speakers and a camera (12MP Center Stage) useful for FaceTime and video — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Apple entering the smart home space more deeply and providing a competitor to Amazon and Google — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • HomeView displays useful info (music, calendar, messages) for living room, kitchen, office, bedside — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Supports partnerships with third-party smart-home makers (LG, Schneider) and HomeKit additions — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Software resembles Apple Watch UI and supports wallpapers/screensavers and CarPlay frameworks (AirPlay, video potential) — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates all smart home accessories and acts as a central hub — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Plays music and can act as a music hub (connects to HomePods, sync playback, shows album art/animations, lyrics) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • FaceTime capability with 12MP camera and Center Stage — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Helps with cooking: extracts recipes, creates ingredient lists, step-by-step guides and timers, hands-free control via Siri — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable cover screens/watch-face style options, widgets, photos and shared albums — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Simplifies smart home complexity by consolidating control into one device/app — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Find My integration (e.g., ask Siri to locate AirTags/keys) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Can play media apps and browse Safari/Podcasts; useful as a standalone screen in rooms like the kitchen/bedroom — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable smart home control dashboard for HomeKit with widgets, camera feeds, and ability to show multiple video feeds (mentioned up to nine) — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Good FaceTime experience with 12 MP Center Stage camera that tracks and zooms during calls — useful for kitchens and extended calls — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Excellent digital picture frame functionality with seamless Photos app integration, shared albums and auto-syncing slideshows — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Supports messages and texting with on-screen keyboard and Siri replies — useful if phone isn't on you — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Supports useful home features like recipes and reminders; can play simple games and videos when paired with your phone. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • First Apple smart HomeHub with a 7-inch Liquid Retina display and Siri AI — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Idle/standby interface offers customizable clock themes and widgets that match room aesthetic — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Acts as a smart home controller/command center for HomeKit-compatible accessories (locks, doorbells, thermostats) — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • 12-megapixel camera with Center Stage for FaceTime, allowing calls without touching iPhone — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Can ping Find My devices (AirTag, iPhone, Apple Watch) from the Home View — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Provides a new dedicated hub (Home View) to manage and monitor smart home devices with a touchscreen interface instead of only voice control — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Acts as both a speaker and a screen (plays music/audio and allows touch control of devices) — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Enables remote monitoring and two-way communication (FaceTime to family members) improving over one-way cameras — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Can display multiple camera feeds (up to nine) simultaneously for home monitoring — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Includes useful features like recipe conversion into step-by-step cooking instructions ('head chef') — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • HomeKit ecosystem provides stable connectivity and allows controlling many third-party devices via Siri without requiring separate apps — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Home View functions as a hub, potentially eliminating the need for separate hubs for many smart devices — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Useful in the kitchen: can display recipes, add to grocery lists, and control timers by voice (hands-free) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Home Camera can show up to nine live camera views at once for security monitoring — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • With iCloud+ and compatible cameras, can recognize people, pets, packages and describe clips — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Can listen for smoke and carbon monoxide alarms (safety feature) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Mirror mode to check appearance at entryway — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Works best as a hub if you already have recent iPhone and smart home devices—can tie ecosystem together — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Fills a gap in Apple's lineup as a dedicated smart home hub / in-home display (similar to Nest Hub or Echo Show). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Supports core smart-home functionality: control lights, view cameras, timers, Siri, play music, open Safari links, view recipes. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Device runs a combination of Apple OS elements (iOS/watchOS-like parts) and provides familiar Apple app experiences (Safari, widgets, etc.). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Direct access to home cameras, doorbells and curated apps from the Home View interface — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable home face (similar to Apple Watch) and swipe-up curated apps (Apple TV, weather, calendar, etc.) — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Works with Matter-compliant accessories and HomeKit; no separate app needed for integration — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates with third-party accessories (e.g., LG cameras) and can access those cameras directly — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Offers a built-in Home View integration with an Apple Home Collection of accessories (potential for tight ecosystem integration) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Official Apple Home View release with hands-on experience — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP center-stage camera for FaceTime and mirror mode — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable dashboard and separate home screens for different people — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Acts as a home hub and connects to Apple Home Collection accessories (cameras, video doorbell) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Can show and answer doorbell and display up to nine camera views — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable display (animated faces, family photos, calendars, interactive Flow face). — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Hands‑free convenience for cooking and everyday tasks: recipe step‑throughs, multiple timers, music handoff from iPhone, reminders, calendar, photos. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Comprehensive smart home control: manage lights, thermostats, locks, cameras, Matter accessories from one screen; view up to nine camera feeds. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • First smart display from Apple with polished software (resembles CarPlay) — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable watch-like/clock faces with multiple widgets and modular layouts — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Includes Safari for browsing (e.g., recipes) and acts as a smart home hub for controls and camera feeds — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Intercom app to broadcast audio messages to Home ecosystem devices — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Handoff support for transferring media and articles from iPhone to Home View seamlessly — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Useful for FaceTime and cooking — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Displays smart home devices and cameras, includes mirror mode — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Handoff support for recipes — optimized cooking view, recognizes timings and allows multiple timers — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP Center Stage camera keeps you centered during FaceTime — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Supports Matter and HomeKit — existing compatible smart devices continue to work — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable display options: animated face, photo space from shared albums — can serve as family photo display — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is a communal family interface for calendar, FaceTime, smart home control, and Siri AI features. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Runs HomeView software similar to iOS, making it familiar and slick. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Supports Safari so users can access most web content. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • No ads in recipe experience (unlike some competitors), which could attract users. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Includes Thread Border router and Matter controller for broad smart home device compatibility. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Built-in A18 chip ready for Siri AI — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Useful smart-home/stationary hub use cases (display for smart home controls, contacts, timers, recipes, etc.) — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP camera with Center Stage — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Home dashboard with widgets and customizable interface (wallpapers, widgets, calendar, etc.) — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Supports home control, music, FaceTime, photos, messaging — similar capabilities to iPad/iPhone — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Acts as a smart home hub—shows recipes, calendar, smart home controls and integrates with Siri AI and personal context — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • 12-megapixel FaceTime camera for video calls and photo display (use as a digital photo album) — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Apple can do an intercom-like functionality (Intercom/announcement across rooms) already, allowing announcements to whole house or a specific room — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Expected new Apple devices (HomePod, HomePod mini, Apple TV, smart hub with a screen) may add two-way communication and FaceTime integration — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Potential upcoming Apple smart hub with video could enable seamless two-way communication, which would address current limitations — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Useful for multitasking in the kitchen with a camera for FaceTime that keeps subjects centered — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Could reduce phone pickups by surfacing calendar, events, and quick Siri questions at a glance — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates into Apple's expanding smart home ecosystem (Home View as a hub) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Home View has a dedicated smart home display experience with dynamic widgets, different faces, smart home controls, and camera integration. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Home View supports viewing up to nine cameras and tapping for a full view with controls. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Home View provides different swipeable faces (like modular face) similar to Apple Watch faces for quick access to date, time, weather, calendar, and photos. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Can act as the Home Hub itself (no need to buy a HomePod) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is a smart home hub with built-in support for Thread, Matter, and other ecosystem features (so you can connect accessories directly to Apple Home). — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Home View works out of the box and integrates seamlessly with the Apple ecosystem, making it easy for less technical users. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • First Apple Home Hub with a screen (Apple Home View). — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates Siri AI for scheduling tasks, reminders, web questions — similar to rival products. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Conversations from a paired iPhone transfer to Home View for continuity. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 12MP FaceTime camera with Center Stage for video calls and following subject within frame. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Access to Safari, Messages, FaceTime, contacts, timers/alarms and Apple Music; some third-party apps expected to be supported. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Can control lights, check cameras, take FaceTime calls, and play music — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates your Home app accessories (lights, locks, thermostat, cameras) in one place for direct control — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Can show up to nine live camera feeds together — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Adds a screen and camera to a HomePod setup — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP FaceTime camera with Center Stage that adjusts framing as you move — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Practical kitchen feature: Start Cooking simplifies recipes for step-by-step hands-free use and manage timers hands-free — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • 12MP Center Stage camera suitable for FaceTime — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI integration: conversational Siri, syncs conversations to Siri app, supports timers, reminders, calendar, live activities, handoff — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Supports Home features like Intercom, pinging AirTags, adjusting thermostat, and works with Apple's new Home accessories — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Includes a 12-megapixel Center Stage camera useful for video calls and automatically following the subject. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 12MP front camera with Center Stage for keeping you centered during video calls — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Unique OS combining elements from other Apple OSes; supports apps that work on CarPlay — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Familiar, customizable home screens and widgets (photos, time, calendar, smart home controls) — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Recipe assistance with seamless transfer from iPhone and step-by-step mode with useful widgets (timers) — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Well-implemented versions of expected smart display features; potentially very useful addition to an Apple smart home — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Combines multiple familiar functions (assistant, music, door camera, calls) into one device — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP camera with Center Stage for video calls that tracks you and includes additional people in frame — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Useful cooking features: step-by-step recipe view, multiple timers, and hands‑free control to keep phone clean — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Centralized smart-home control (lighting, thermostat, locks) with scenes and multi-camera display — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Secure video monitoring and intelligent recording analysis for cameras — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Detects smoke and CO alarm sounds and can send alerts to iPhone/Apple Watch as an extra safety notification — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Supports Matter and non‑Apple compatible accessories (works with compatible third‑party devices) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Apple expanding Home ecosystem with new Home Collection accessories (cameras, thermostat, locks) from partners — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Can walk you through recipes step by step, control lights and locks, show cameras, and handle FaceTime and messages — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Helps households keep track of who needs to be where and when — useful for families and people running businesses — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Could serve as a stationary, table‑centered device for hotels or similar settings (replace in‑room tablets to control services and environment). — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Functions similarly to an iPad — can do recipes, basic questions, calendar, reminders, FaceTime (implied functionality available). — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates a screen with HomePod speaker to serve as a smart home hub — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Controls smart home, shows calendar/events, camera feeds, door visitor, reminders, Messages, FaceTime, Apple TV, and timers — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Includes Safari browser and can receive video via AirPlay — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Front-facing camera and microphones support FaceTime and user recognition — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • HomeView OS with custom watch-face-like main page and customizable widgets (e.g., multi-camera view) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Includes built-in apps and can use iPhone widgets/apps (existing CarPlay integration and widgets likely to work) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Has Safari/web browser (possible route to access streaming/web content like YouTube) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Deep Apple integration (native access to things like Calendar, Reminders, Notes, Apple Music — more integrated than Echo Show) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates Apple's ecosystem (iPhone, Watch, HomePod, Apple TV) into one dedicated home control screen — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable home-focused interface with clock faces, widgets, and app-style dashboard — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Useful for people deep in Apple's ecosystem—makes routines easier — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Designed as a dedicated smart home device (not a personal iPad) for shared household use and automations — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Supports household automations, smart accessories, and a shared experience across family members — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Central location for family schedules and relevant information, useful for families to stay organized — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Can consolidate control of multiple smart home systems (cameras, lights, thermostat, scenes) into one screen without needing a phone — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Functions as a home hub to manage compatible accessories and automations remotely — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Seamless integration with Apple's ecosystem (iPhone, Mac, Apple Watch, etc.) — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Convenience of a dedicated, always-placed device that understands different household members and manages the home — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Apple allowing developers to bring compatible video apps to HomeView is a positive step toward entertainment functionality — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Keeps the whole house connected (smart home hub capability) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Hands-free FaceTime support (useful for kitchen/when multitasking) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Apple Home Collection accessories (cameras, thermostats, door locks) designed for simple setup and use — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Front camera with Center Stage for FaceTime — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Includes ambient light sensor, accelerometer, and temperature/humidity sensor (can feed new smart thermostats) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Handoff music from iPhone by holding near Home View — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Interface adapts with distance (simple info from afar, more detail up close) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Customizable 'faces' (photos with depth effects, flow/interactive art, Snoopy animations, home modular face for quick accessory controls, camera face showing up to nine feeds) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Kitchen features: turns web recipes into step‑by‑step instructions with hands‑free timers and ingredient tracking — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Supports FaceTime and Intercom — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Third‑party apps can work via a CarPlay‑style integration (Spotify, Audible, etc. supported if they support CarPlay) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Launches with an Apple Home Collection of accessories (cameras, doorbell, deadbolt, thermostats) that set up with one‑tap for iPhone — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Serves as a central home hub for HomeKit: manage calendar, FaceTime, reminders, check camera feeds and run automations — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Useful kitchen features (follow recipes, tap timers to set them on the device) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • 12-megapixel camera with Center Stage for tracked FaceTime framing — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Central smart home control for lights, locks, cameras, thermostat from screen or via Siri — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Can show doorbell visitors and control devices remotely (e.g., turn off lights from couch) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Supports automations (scenes like good night to turn off lights, lock doors, change thermostat) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Supports Matter and Thread for compatibility with third-party smart home products — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Positions itself as center of your Apple home—one place to manage lights, cameras, doors, music, FaceTime, calendars, reminders — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad (makeshift Home View app) can put live camera feeds from HomeKit on an iPad — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • App can show thermostat controls, brightness, garage doors, and analog/digital clock like HomeView — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • You can create up to 20 pages of controls in the HomePad app (more than HomeView) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad integrates directly with Apple Home devices and pulls scenes, accessories, sensors — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Any added camera in the app is a live view and supports multiple cameras at once — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Home view (Apple) changes depending on who approaches it (multiple-user awareness) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Home view has specific features like displaying recipes inline with timers and visual timers — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Home view should turn on when you approach it and show relevant information (proactive/ambient behavior) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad app lets you resize widgets (small, medium, large) and arrange controls freely — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Medium/large widgets in HomePad offer direct controls like a dimming bar for lights — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad supports up to six widgets per page and up to 20 pages total — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad offers wallpaper and customization (including glassiness level and custom photos) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad can keep the iPad screen awake while the app is open — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Introduces a dedicated screen for the home (new product category) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • 12MP center stage camera for video calls and framing — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Sensors for temperature, humidity, and ambient light — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition for up to six people, enabling personalized content — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Supports classic home features: timers, photos, music, handoff, widgets, and FaceTime — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates Siri AI for context-aware, capable assistant functionality — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Center Stage camera follows you and includes others for better family communication — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Integration with third‑party accessories (LG, Schneider) brought into Apple's privacy-focused ecosystem and easy one-tap setup — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Adaptive UI that shows big information from afar and more detail when you approach — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition for up to six people, offering personal home screens, apps, and widgets — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI: new conversational Siri capable of contextual, personal requests when paired with Apple Intelligence iPhone/iPad, with conversation handoff to other devices — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Home hub functionality: control locks, thermostats, lights, blinds by touch or voice — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Can stream up to nine camera feeds, with iCloud+ features for person/pet/package/vehicle recognition and clip descriptions — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Safety features: listens for smoke and CO alarms and alerts your iPhone — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Useful day-to-day features: FaceTime with Center Stage, Intercom, recipe step-by-step cooking with hands-free timers, Handoff for media, and art/photo display modes — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Built-in temperature and humidity sensor that can feed automations — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Deep integration with Apple ecosystem — ideal if your home already runs on Apple devices — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Можна слухати музику, здійснювати дзвінки по FaceTime та дивитися відео з домашніх камер — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Корисний на кухні — показує рецепти та допомагає з таймерами (не потрібно брати телефон брудними руками) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Підтримка Central Stage для кращих дзвінків по FaceTime (тримає в кадрі) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Працює як хаб для управління розумним домом (виведення відео з камер) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • HomePod (колонка) отримала нові корисні оновлення (Sound Glow, підтримка як бездротова колонка для Mac тощо) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Sound Glow — верхня сенсорна панель перетворюється на світломузику — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Розпізнавання звуку пожежної сигналізації або датчика чадного газу і надсилання сповіщення — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Apple Home Collection — продумана екосистема аксесуарів (розумний замок, термостати, камери) з простим підключенням до iPhone — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Розумний замок з Ultra Wideband, що відкриває двері при підході з iPhone/Apple Watch — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Design & Build Quality (74)
  • Apple-esque design that reviewer loves — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Camera and speakers built into the display and base — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Slick design and good fit as a smart home centerpiece if used as intended. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Solid build materials (mostly metal) and articulated display — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Color-matching base and multiple color options for the stand version — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Compact, intentional size that blends into the home (not meant to replace an iPad) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple color choices and wall-mounted version for flexible placement — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Attractive, high-quality design with four colors and color-matched USB-C cables; reminiscent of the iMac G4 and ideal for countertop placement with a 7in square display — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Designed to be minimal — everything you need and nothing more, which helps avoid distractions. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version has an appealing look (described as like a giant Apple Watch on the wall). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Apple invested a lot of work into creating a home display — implies solid design and integration. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Design reminiscent of iMac G4 — simple, futuristic, quintessentially Apple — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Available in four color variants (silver, Starlight, Rose Pink, space gray) — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Can include a stand with built-in speakers or be wall-mounted, offering installation flexibility — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Sleek, minimalist design that doesn't take up much space — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Available as tabletop (with larger speaker/woofer) or wall-mounted version (offers installation flexibility). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Convenient USB-C power on the tabletop version so you can plug it in where you want. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Available in tabletop (with louder, clearer base speaker) or wall-mounted versions — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Comes in multiple colors and offers customization options — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Design is described as lovely and Apple has the right idea for the product — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • New product category designed as the heart of the house with a built-in 7-inch display and integrated speakers/HomePod, good for congregating and interacting in shared spaces — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Available wall-mounted and tabletop versions (same price) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Available in two versions (stand and wall-mounted) giving choice — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Stand version has adjustable stainless steel hinge (up/down) and comes in four subtle colors — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Stand version includes USB-C cable and 30W power adapter in the box — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Beautiful, premium design with a 7‑inch Liquid Retina display, aluminum speaker base, adjustable stainless steel hinge, and multiple color options (tabletop and wall‑mountable). — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Swivels / hinge lets you adjust viewing angle (up/down) — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Two form factors: tabletop with built-in speakers and wall-mounted option — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple power options including PoE and USB; magnetic mount for the tablet portion — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Available in multiple colors (space gray, silver, starlight, rose pink) — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Doesn't swivel to follow you (presented as a positive for privacy/comfort). — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • High-quality materials and attractive design/form factor — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Two configuration options (tabletop and wall-mounted) with tabletop recommended for most people — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Two different models (tabletop with speaker and wall‑mounted) and multiple colors — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall‑mount version offers options (USB‑C, AC wired, PoE) including a PoE option for clean installation — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Offers two styles: regular tabletop and wall-mounted, giving installation options — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Brand-new product category—a dedicated smart home device that can be tabletop or wall-mounted (flexible placement) — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Adjustable angle on the tabletop base for an immersive viewing experience — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Available in multiple colors with a solid industrial design that blends well with modern interiors; wall-mount option provides a sleek finish — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Looks slick and has strong potential — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Two versions: tabletop and wall-mounted, giving installation flexibility. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Two form factors: tabletop and wall-mounted versions — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop version includes 30-W power adapter and 1.5-m USB-C cable — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop design has a stainless steel hinge for smooth tilt and comfortable viewing — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple power options for wall-mounted unit (20-W adapter, third-party mounts with USB-C, hardwired mount, future PoE) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Comes with a power adapter in-box (USB-C) which is convenient. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Two models (dock with extra speakers or wall-mounted) give placement flexibility. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Looks cool and matches expectations; well-designed aesthetic — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Unusual, attractive design with a small square screen on a rounded aluminum base and adjustable tilt — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple color options (silver, space gray, starlight, rose pink) and matching power cable for aesthetics — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mountable option (convenient for entrances) — separate mount available — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Small, compact design reminiscent of older iMac aesthetic (7-inch screen, neat form factor for sitting on a table). — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Available in two versions: with speaker stand or wall-mountable (flexible placement) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Compact seven-inch square touchscreen with tiltable hinge (space-saving, adjustable) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Type-C charger for easy unplugging and relocating — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch square tilting touchscreen with adjustable angle — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Premium build (metal, compact footprint) feels more premium than basic smart displays — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Distinctive design that some may find elegant — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted and freestanding options (different colors/finishes available for some models) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple color options for tabletop model (silver, starlight, rose pink, space gray) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Available in multiple colors and has a nostalgic, attractive design (7in square, rounded corners) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Compact, cute design and Apple experimenting with new product category — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Compact 7-inch Liquid Retina display on a small speaker base that fits on a counter, desk, or nightstand — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Available wall-mounted version to serve as a futuristic smart home control panel — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Tiltable display with speaker stand (tilt up/down) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Attractive design and high build quality; 'cute' and appealing aesthetic — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Innovative device combining a 7-in square Liquid Retina display with a domed speaker and polished hinge for adjustable tilt — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Eco-friendly base made from 100% recycled aluminum — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Wall model tuned for wall use (alternative mounting option) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop model includes 30W power adapter in the box — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • High-quality hardware and premium design (early hands-on called it the highest-quality smart display) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Симпатичний дизайн смарт‑дисплея з семидюймовим екраном та регульованим нахилом — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Є версія для кріплення на стіну — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Стильно та футуристично виглядає у відеорекламі — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Smart Assistant Performance (64)
  • Fast account switching using facial recognition to give personal context for up to six people — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Can recognize up to six different people and provide contextual, personalized info — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Introduces face recognition system that enables convenient multi-user support and potential face-unlock use cases — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Manages calendar, messages, reminders, and helps answer quick questions via Siri/Apple Intelligence — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Facial recognition for personalized, multi-user experiences (up to six people) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Great notification hub for up to six family members with individual logins and fast authentication (face, voice, proximity) that syncs personal apps (calendar, reminders, messages, Apple Music) — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Improves Siri experience in the kitchen via on-screen Siri AI/chatbot with personal context and ability to show images, recipes, and other results on the display — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Supports multiple users (up to six) with facial verification for personalized access and privacy — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Can recognize up to six people and show personalized content (messages, calendar, reminders, FaceTime) — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Uses Siri AI to summarize home activity (who arrived, what's happening) leveraging on-device AI — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six people by face and gives each person a personalized home screen with their own apps and widgets — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Built around Siri AI for conversational, more capable assistant interactions — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Combines face recognition, screen, Siri and smart home features to act as a personal assistant for each family member — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Fast multi-user switching using facial recognition (up to six users) to provide personalized content (messages, calendar, etc.). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Uses a 12MP Center Stage selfie camera for reliable face recognition and interaction; works with nearby unlocked iPhone/iPad context. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Siri built in with improved smart capabilities and useful conversational queries — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Personalized Siri experience that recognizes who is talking and can authenticate using nearby devices — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • World knowledge via Siri and synchronized search requests across devices (if enabled) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six people and customizes experience per family member — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Includes Siri AI with personal context (can access messages, play specific shared songs, give travel timing, etc.) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Apple intelligence can summarize supported camera recordings and send alerts (e.g., smoke/CO alarms) to Apple devices. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Enhanced Siri AI: more natural conversations, follow‑ups, broader knowledge and integration with personal data when paired with compatible iPhone/iPad; conversations continue across Apple devices. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Supports face recognition to surface personalized content for different family members — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes household members and brings up personalized home screen, widgets, and apps — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Siri works similarly to iPhone and can do multi-step, personal-context tasks with a paired Apple device — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Multi-user support with face and voice recognition to show each person their own calendar, messages, and music library. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Siri can walk you through recipes by breaking them into steps for easy following. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Personal context features: facial recognition and support for up to six people with Apple ID/iPhone integration — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Can recognize up to six different people and provide secure, personalized experiences for each user — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Uses Siri AI (starting in English) with contextual understanding and syncing across your Apple devices/accounts — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Ability to recognize faces to provide personalized content — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Identifies up to six different users and provides personalized dashboards (multi-user personalization) — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Supports up to six people with their own apps and widgets and provides personal access to information — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Supports multiple users (up to six profiles) with face unlock for privacy — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is designed for multi-user personalization — can support and recognize up to six different people, providing each with their own personal content and guest modes. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Can recognize and personalize for up to six different people (voice recognition tied to individual accounts). — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes who's using it so one screen can work for the whole family (personalization) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Person recognition for up to six people with personalized home screens, apps, and widgets and private content — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six different Apple accounts so multiple household members can get personalized information. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition for showing personal info could be seamless and simple if it works as demoed. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI integration with personal context from nearby Apple devices for seamless, personalized queries — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Improved Siri / Apple Intelligence expected to better understand natural speech and help with tasks — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Can access personal info (messages, calendars) from compatible iPhone/iPad to answer personal queries with permission — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six family members and shows personalized info while protecting personal data with additional checks — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI built in to answer questions and assist — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six people and provides each person their own home screen (personalized calendar, reminders, messages) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Deep integration across family members makes it more useful the more people use it — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Fast account switching via face recognition for up to six household members, each with personal data and music — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Multiple household members can get a personalized experience — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Potential to use Siri AI to interact, send messages with voice, and surface AI-driven info — untapped value — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Fast account switching using 12MP Center Stage camera for up to six personal experiences (shows each person's calendar, etc.) — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Can detect nearby unlocked iPhone or Apple Watch to help identify users — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Siri handles timers, weather, music, and supported tasks; supports iPhone tap-to-transfer and moving FaceTime calls to the screen — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Can recognize up to six different household members and provide personalized information for each person — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by Siri and integrated into the Apple ecosystem (phone, watch, TV, etc.) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Recognizes up to six people for personalized experiences (profiles, messages, etc.) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Shared device that recognizes up to six people by face and voice, giving each person a personal home screen with apps and widgets — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Supports multiple personal profiles (up to six) with face recognition and automatic profile switching — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Siri can answer more complicated questions, use info from your Apple devices, and provide personalized help (calendar, messages, reminders, cooking assistance) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition for up to six people to show personalized information (calendar, reminders, messages, FaceTime) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Designed as a personal assistant for the whole family with automatic profile switching — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Головна фішка — Apple Intelligence і покращена Siri (потенційно корисно) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Розпізнавання до шести членів родини (персоналізація) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Підтримка функції показу персональних повідомлень/нагадувань при розпізнаванні обличчя (приватний контекст) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Sound Quality (43)
  • Speaker quality claimed to be top-notch and supports spatial sound — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Sound quality is fine with bass from the subwoofer in the base and no notable distortion at higher volumes — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Stand version includes a woofer and comes with a 30W power adapter (better built-in sound for that model). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Good speaker potential — speaker quality will be an important factor; excitement about trying it suggests expected good audio and OS polish. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Built-in microphone and speaker described as incredibly sensitive; can pick up voice from far away — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Can be used as a speaker to listen to music (speaker holes on display and stand) — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Delivers premium sound with multi-driver design (two full-range drivers, downward-firing woofer, passive radiators) — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop version's speaker sounded very good in impressions (better than Nest Hub Mini). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop model includes an extra speaker around the base for better sound — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Audio: version with woofer (bass) and passive radiators provides better sound; sounds very good in brief test — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Strong audio hardware: two full‑range speakers, down‑firing woofer, passive radiators delivering spatial, room‑filling sound and rich bass. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 12 MP Center Stage camera and four beamforming microphones for good video calls and Siri voice pickup. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Acts like a HomePod with a base — you can talk to it from across the room — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Decent built-in audio for its size; tabletop model has two full-range drivers, down-firing woofer, and passive radiators; supports multi-room AirPlay — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Speaker system included and generally good use cases — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Four beam‑forming microphones — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Built‑in speaker with spatial audio and AirPlay support for multiroom music — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Includes a woofer in the regular (stand) model to enhance sound — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Built-in speaker with a woofer in the base—functions as a more powerful HomePod-like smart speaker — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • HomePod and HomePod mini have better speaker quality (implied) compared to cheaper alternatives — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop version includes a woofer and a 30W cable/charger; wall version has built-in smaller woofers in the display. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop version has speakers in the display and a woofer in the base (potentially good audio) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop version has stronger speaker hardware (two full-range drivers, down-firing woofer, force-canceling passive radiators) for improved bass — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • HomePod View supports spatial audio (unlike HomePod mini) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Four-microphone array (front, back, left, right) similar to larger HomePod — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Good speakers on the countertop version with impressive bass — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version’s speakers are designed to use reflections so sound isn’t muffled — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Four microphones to isolate voice and reduce background noise for remote voice pickup — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version still plays sound (speakers in screen and stand) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Aluminum design with built-in woofer and bass radiators plus bottom speaker grills — overall sound is pretty good and on par with HomePod minis — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Stand version includes a woofer for fuller sound — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Spatial audio and FaceTime features supported — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop model has substantial audio hardware (two full‑range drivers, down‑firing woofer, passive radiators) and supports room‑filling spatial audio and multi‑room audio — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version tuned to sound better on a wall (same price as stand version) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Decent built-in speaker in the base; sounds quite good — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Built-in speakers for music, video, FaceTime, and photos—functions expected of an Apple home device — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Optional speaker base with down-firing woofer, passive radiators, and full-range drivers (better audio when chosen) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Even the wall-mounted version has full-range drivers (provides audio without speaker base) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Four mics that pick up voice across the room (good for Siri/Siri AI interaction) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Advanced sound system with two full-range drivers in the display and a down-firing woofer plus force-canceling passive radiators for deep bass without vibration — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • A18 chip with computational audio for real-time tuning, Dolby Atmos support, and multi-speaker playback around the home — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Добра якість звучання — «класно звучить» — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Можливість створити домашній кінотеатр зі 4 колонок та автоматичне калібрування звуку — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Display Quality (34)
  • 7-inch touchscreen display suitable as a controller/connector for thermostats, doorbells, cameras, etc. — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Display looks decent: LCD up to 500 nits, True Tone, very dim minimum (0.3 nits) making it suitable for bedrooms — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch Liquid Retina display with good brightness range (0.3 to 500 nits) suitable for daytime use and very dim at night — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Works well as a nightstand control hub with very low minimum brightness (0.3 nits) and customizable standby mode — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Nice screen: Liquid Retina LCD up to 500 nits. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch Liquid Retina display with automatic brightness adjustment and interface that adapts to user distance — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Screen adapts to distance—shows bigger simpler info from afar and more detail up close — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch square LCD with True Tone that adapts well (nice little screen). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Retina / Super Retina 1:1 display — very vibrant, very sharp and smooth — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Same 7-inch Liquid Retina display with decent 500 nits brightness — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Presence‑aware interface that reveals more information as you approach and auto‑adjusts brightness from 500 nits to 0.3 nits at night. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch square (1:1) liquid retina display with A18 chip — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Very dim minimum brightness (0.3 nits) — good beside bed; also 500 nits max — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • True Tone and ambient light sensor — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch display with True Tone and wide brightness range (500 nits down to 0.3 nits) — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • New 6‑inch square display device with a clean Apple design and expected great display quality — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Includes a beautiful screen — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch Liquid Retina display with wide brightness range (500 nits to 3 nits) for good visibility day/night — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch square Retina display, up to 500 nits brightness and down to 0.3 nits for night use. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch (6.98-in) Liquid Retina IPS display with True Tone and oleophobic coating — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Comfortable brightness range: 500 nits max (good for indoors) and very low 0.3 nits minimum for nightstand use — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch Liquid Retina display that looks good up close and from across a room — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Display adapts information based on distance (large clock/weather from afar, more controls when closer) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch screen that sits on your counter or mounts on your wall — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Display brightness range 0.3–500 nits and True Tone support (good for bright rooms and low-light/bedroom use) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch display with very low minimum brightness (0.3 nits) suitable for bedrooms and bright max (up to 500 nits) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Screen quality: up to ~500 nits, dims to ~0.3 nits, and True Tone adjusts to room — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch Liquid Retina display with 500 nits brightness and 12MP Center Stage FaceTime camera — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • 7‑inch square Liquid Retina LCD with True Tone and up to 500 nits brightness (very dimmining to 0.3 nits for nightstand use) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Display supports True Tone and has good viewing angles despite being LCD — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Very low minimum brightness (0.3 nits) useful as a nightstand device and maxes at 500 nits — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Auto-adjusting screen brightness to ambient light — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch square display with 500 nits peak brightness and very low 0.3 nits minimum (good for bedside use) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • High-quality display: 1088 x 1088 pixels, 500 nits peak brightness and can dim to 0.3 nits — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
Privacy & Security (27)
  • Has face/voice-based privacy features to hide others' content when different people use it. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy controls to choose which personal information is shown; falls back to non-personal responses when no recognized user — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Keeps personal content private from others in the household according to Apple, and processes Siri requests on-device or on private servers — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Front-facing camera with multi-user facial recognition (works with iPhone for added security) — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Security measures: uses front-facing camera (not Face ID) and checks proximity/last iPhone unlock — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition for up to six people with personalized experiences (calendars, reminders, apps) while protecting privacy with A18 secure enclaves and nearby unlocked iPhone/iPad requirement. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Identification processing is local and recognition can be turned off for privacy — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Guest mode with configurable access (lights, shared music, Safari) without giving personal content; guests don't need an iPhone to use guest mode — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy/security: locks personal information if someone else grabs the device — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • On‑device Siri processing when possible plus Apple's private cloud compute for privacy; data not stored — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy-aware design and personal data blending with Siri AI for contextual responses (privacy noted) — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Device not sending voice recordings to Apple; updates/changes secured locally and user alerted when server usage is required. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Facial and voice recognition stored in secure enclave to switch personal info between users securely — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Design prioritizes privacy — sensitive actions require proximity of an unlocked Apple device (iPhone) as confirmation — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • On‑device secure processing for face/voice recognition and claims of not storing user requests in cloud — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Strong privacy and security design: data processed in a secure part of the chip and inaccessible to apps or Apple — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Personal content only shows when HomeView recognizes your face and a nearby iPhone/iPad was recently unlocked (prevents guests from reading your texts) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • For privacy-focused users, probably the most private smart home screen available — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy behavior: switches view/contents when another person tries to access it — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Strong privacy model: personal info requires face recognition and nearby unlocked paired iPhone/iPad — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy: face recognition data is processed and stored locally thanks to the A18 chip — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Apple emphasizes privacy and security with personalized info kept separate per user — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Strong privacy design (requires nearby unlocked Apple device to access personal content) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • On-device secure processing: camera and mics feed a secure enclave so personal data is protected and not accessible by apps or Apple — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy gating for personal content: requires face recognition, nearby unlocked iPhone/iPad on same Wi‑Fi, and recent unlock — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Flexible request processing: runs on-device or in Apple's private cloud with no data storage — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Кімнатна камера має фішку — опускає об'єктив вниз, коли член родини повертається додому (конфіденційність) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Value for Money (24)
  • Reasonable hands-free and shared family experience for $299 if you are invested in Apple ecosystem — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Good value as a smart speaker at $299 (cheaper than $349 HomePod) with down-firing subwoofer, passive radiators, two full-range drivers, and spatial audio support — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Cheaper than pairing a base iPad with a HomePod (HomeView is $300 vs ~$600–$800 for iPad+HomePod configurations). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Priced at $299 and available for pre-order with a set availability date — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Price point stated (USD 299) — positioned as a premium but clear pricing — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Reasonable launch price ($299) and available November 13 — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • $299 price point offers a reasonable family entry point to a central Siri assistant — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Pre-orders available and launch date provided (Nov 13) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Same starting price ($299) for tabletop and wall‑mounted versions. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Good value within Apple ecosystem: acts as smart home controller, entertainment display, FaceTime device, and AI assistant in one. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is priced at $300 (with options for speaker base or wall-mount), positioned as a premium product. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Pleasant price point ($299) for the Home View — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Good option now for buyers who want a stationary home base without waiting for Pro version — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Relatively affordable base price of $299 for the device — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Priced and availability stated (₹39,900, available Nov 13) — clarity for buyers — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Availability starts November 13 and price starts at $299 (clear launch info). — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Surprisingly low starting price of $299 for both versions — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Reasonably priced at $299 for standard and wall-mounted versions (mount sold separately) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Reasonably priced Apple accessories in the Home Collection (fits pricing of devices) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Priced right at $299 for the base version (surprisingly reasonable compared to full-size HomePod) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Reasonable price point at $300 — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Cheapest entry point to Apple intelligence / new Siri AI at $299 compared with iPad or other Apple devices — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad is free to download and integrates with your current Apple Home — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Good price point at $299 (UK/US) — perceived as strong value for Apple product — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
Connectivity & Compatibility (22)
  • Supports CarPlay standard beaming from iPhone and tap-to-beam for music, Safari content, and FaceTime — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Handoff support for audio (Apple Music, podcasts, audiobooks) allowing instant transfer from iPhone and full-screen music controls/lyrics — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates CarPlay framework so apps that support CarPlay can show content (and non-Apple apps that support CarPlay can work). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Can connect with other HomePods in the house — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Supports CarPlay apps (Spotify via CarPlay) so compatible audio/video apps can run on it — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Siri queries and history sync to other devices (handoff to iPhone/iPad) for continuity — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Compatibility listed with Apple Home collection accessories planned from partners (LG, Schneider) — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Extends Apple ecosystem—can display Safari, messages, and other content so you don’t need to take out your phone — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Apple has an ecosystem that the speaker is moving into and appreciates for ease of use (iPhone, MacBook Pro, etc.) — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Arrives alongside other Apple home products and ecosystem features (e.g., HomePods, Apple TV integration) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Connects with HomePods through AirPlay for multiroom music and supports Intercom — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • AirPlay support to stream audio to other speakers (including HomePods) and view album art/lyrics on display — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Ties together existing Apple devices in the home (iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple TV) to create tight integration — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates with HomeKit ecosystem and Apple Home Collection accessories (native device support) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Supports AirPlay (so you should be able to send compatible phone video/audio to the device) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Handoff support to phone for songs, podcasts, video calls — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Supports selection of Apple apps and compatible third-party audio/video apps from iPhone — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Tight integration with Apple ecosystem — personal contacts, calendar, messages available for deep Apple users — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Makes most sense within Apple's ecosystem—tight integration with iPhone, Apple services, and existing HomeKit devices — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Connectivity: Wi‑Fi 6E, Bluetooth 6, and Thread; can act as a smart home hub — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Works with Matter accessories and includes Thread radio for low-power mesh networking — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • HomePod можна використовувати як стандартну бездротову колонку для Mac (за умови сучасного Mac з Wi‑Fi 6E) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Performance & Reliability (18)
  • Runs on an A18 chip and a dedicated HomeView OS with familiar Apple UI elements and customization — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Equipped with A18 chip enabling advanced features and Siri AI functionality — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Integrates an Apple A18 chip to support Siri AI and on-device intelligence — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by an A18 processor with dynamic photo frames and personalized experiences for up to six people — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Good replacement for older smart displays (e.g., Google Home Hub) due to improved speed and capabilities — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by A18 chip (same as iPhone 16/16 Plus) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is expected to provide a smoother daily-use and maintenance experience compared with hacked/custom setups. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by the A18 chip (plenty fast for Siri AI and general tasks) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • A18 chip inside so it can run Siri AI locally on the device. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by Apple A18 chip enabling responsive voice assistant, multi-user recognition, and home control — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Runs on Apple A18 processor and supports full Apple Intelligence / smart Siri — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Runs on an A18 chip (implies snappy performance) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Potentially more responsive/reliable than the user's current Amazon Hub — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • A18 chip (same as iPhone 16) — modern, powerful silicon — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Includes A18 chip and supports Apple Intelligence / new Siri AI (where available) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Restricted app environment may make it safer and more reliable for family/home use — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Runs on Apple A18 chip and new Siri AI promising much more capable voice assistant behavior — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by A18 chip (modern, capable silicon) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
Ease of Use (8)
  • Ties into ease of use and quality Apple is known for — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Single-layer user interface that makes it easy to focus on the task without getting distracted. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Setup via iPhone or iPad that personalizes apps and information — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Good potential for older users: large, easy-to-see UI, simple video calling with Center Stage, loud and easy to hear. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Likely seamless Apple ecosystem compatibility and easy setup with other Apple devices. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Touchscreen works well for pulling up control panels, camera views, and thermostat controls — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Always-in-place touchscreen that makes quick interactions (like turning off lights) more convenient than unlocking an iPad — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Fluid, Apple-like OS and UI experience — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
Other (6)
  • HomeKit compatible — can control lights, locks, heating/cooling and show up to nine camera feeds at once. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Powered by an A18 chip with 8 GB RAM — on-device Siri AI processing and local storage of voice data for improved privacy. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Good fit for households already using Apple devices and services — dedicated place to see and control everything — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Modern connectivity: Wi‑Fi 6E, Bluetooth 6, and Thread support — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Reasonably priced at $300—cheaper than the cheapest iPad, making it more accessible as a stationary HomePod-with-screen device. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Runs almost a full watchOS clock-face app for nightstand mode and can dim to under one nit—very low minimum brightness for comfortable night use. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch

Cons (335)

Features & Functionality (95)
  • No App Store — no third-party native apps run on the device (limited to CarPlay-standard apps and AirPlay) — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Lack of features — perceived limited necessity and unclear value proposition — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • HomeView software is 'weird' and reliant on iPhone (needs iPhone to work) — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • No official App Store on the device — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Some partnered devices don't appear to offer exclusive features beyond HomeKit additions — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Limited app experiences mentioned (wants TikTok scrolling but not confirmed) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • No video playback support — no Apple TV app and limited/worse experience for widescreen video watching on the square display — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • No App Store — cannot install third-party apps (e.g., YouTube) or run many external apps directly on the device; limited to Apple's apps — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Feels like an iPad with a speaker but with limitations similar to the Apple Watch (limited apps and functionality). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Many features you want on the HomeView can already be done on an Apple Watch or iPad. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • No native video apps and no App Store at launch — any video must be streamed from your iPhone, limiting standalone functionality. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Apple doesn't manufacture many smart home devices itself — relies on third-party partners, so hardware variety depends on partners — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Apple's smart-home approach previously offered limited device management options (mostly voice/hubs); Home View addresses that but implies prior gaps — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI is still in beta (not finished) and some features have daily limits; expanded access may cost a fee in the future — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Requires recent iPhone/iPad that supports Apple intelligence for personal Siri features (limited to newer models) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Some smart camera features require compatible cameras and a paid iCloud Plus plan (additional cost and limitations) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Limited app ecosystem: no App Store, only a set of Apple-optimized apps; Safari-only browsing, cannot use other browsers. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Many features are tied to specific Apple apps (e.g., recipe tap-in requires Safari on phone), limiting cross-platform flexibility. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • No native Spotify or other popular apps unless they support CarPlay; reliance on AirPlay/CarPlay support is restrictive. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Product feels like a half computer / half ambient device — somewhat limited compared to expectations (some novelty features may wear off). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Curated apps are not from the App Store — no general App Store access on Home View — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Reviewer wanted wider screen format and more functionalities — limited by current form-factor/features — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Does not support installing additional third-party apps (only a handful of built-in apps and limited audio/video apps via an approval process) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Limited personalization: only recognizes/personalizes for up to six people — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Personal context requires users to have an iPhone that supports Siri AI (device-dependent) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear support for existing HomeKit accessories — uncertain whether all current devices (e.g., many Hue lights) will appear or be controllable in Home View — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Potentially not a good purchase if you have a lot of HomeKit accessories until compatibility details are clarified (recommendation to pause if you have many accessories) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI launches in English with beta features and usage limits; some advanced capabilities depend on connected devices and supported features. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Certain advanced Siri and smart camera features have additional device requirements or subscriptions, potentially increasing real cost. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Limited widget slots on modular face (only about four) which may constrain customization — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Face/recognition is not Face ID — requires a paired iPhone/iPad nearby and recently unlocked; may ask phone authentication if uncertain — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Limited native apps at launch (only a few Apple apps visible), relying on third-party developers to add support. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Apps are not installed locally; Home View displays apps from a connected device (CarPlay-like), which may limit functionality. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Requires iPhone 17 series or newer to use Siri AI personal context features. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Risk that families will continue using their iPhones instead of the shared Home View, making it a glorified speaker/picture frame. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Because it relies heavily on Siri AI, Home View won't be available in the EU at launch. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Software supports multi-user use but hardware form factor feels designed for single-person use — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI will start in English and some features may be region/language limited at launch — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Some Home Collection accessories are shown as unavailable with no release dates — ecosystem incomplete at launch — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Confusing/product decisions around accessory compatibility labeling (Apple keeps updating compatibility labels) — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • No explicit drawbacks mentioned, but implied dependency on Siri AI features that may arrive later (some key functionality like Siri AI integration may require future updates) — Technical Guruji · ▶ Watch
  • Apple lacks a true drop-in two-way intercom feature (only has announcement-style Intercom), which is a primary reason the speaker stays with Amazon Alexa — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Intercom on Apple is one-way announcement-like (compared to Alexa's instant two-way drop-in), feels archaic and less useful for real-time conversation — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Current Apple smart home devices (pre-new release) are leaving users behind on two-way intercom functionality — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Limited app ecosystem: only 15 built-in apps and no App Store (restricted functionality) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Potential for family friction (kids grabbing the device) and questions about how multi-user behavior will work — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Limited interoperability discussion with existing non-Apple smart home devices (unclear how it works with Google/Nest or Amazon) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is perceived by some as limited/locked down (no app store/custom apps), reducing flexibility compared with an iPad + Home Assistant. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Home View may lack some advanced/custom features (e.g., custom vacuum pop-ups or highly tailored dashboards) that power users can build with Home Assistant on an iPad. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Because Home View is more locked down, it may not offer the same level of customization or third-party integrations that DIY/Home Assistant setups provide. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop camera/module cannot physically rotate to follow you — limited to digital Center Stage within framing. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear third-party app support at launch (Netflix/Spotify compatibility not confirmed). — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Personal Siri features require a paired Apple Intelligence-enabled device (supported iPhones start with 15 Pro), limiting functionality for some users — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Buying HomeView doesn't make ordinary lights, locks, or thermostats smart — accessories and additional budget are needed — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Some camera features (recording, intelligent summaries, searching recorded clips) need the right iCloud+ plan and compatible setup — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • If you already have an Alexa/Echo Show setup that works, switching may not be worth it and not all accessories/cameras/routines will transfer even with Matter — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Limited third-party app support — no native third-party apps (e.g., no YouTube app); must cast some iPhone apps via CarPlay backend — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Casting from iPhone may be slower and not all apps can be cast — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Confusion about OS identity (not iOS) and what apps/features (e.g., join meeting links, photo editing) are supported—limited app capability compared to iPad/iPhone. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Launch timing and ecosystem readiness issues: many Home accessories and setup details are still 'coming later', reducing immediate usefulness. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Not many truly new features compared with existing smart displays — mostly well-implemented but familiar functionality — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Some personal features require a compatible iPhone or iPad — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Not officially sold in the European Union at launch — regional feature limitations possible — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Apple's AI runs inside Apple's walls with Apple's rules, which can prevent external agents from integrating (limits interoperability) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Real example: some AI agents (like Muse) have trouble interacting with Apple Calendar compared to Google Calendar — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI launches on HomeView as a beta and isn't even on the new HomePod Mini at launch (feature rollout incomplete) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Limited utility — meant only to sit on a table, lacking unique features beyond form factor. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • No YouTube app or other third-party apps / no app store — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • User recognition requires camera to see you (no voice-based account switching) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • HomeView OS lacks apps like YouTube/Netflix and has no app store (limited media/apps natively) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Many features and ecosystem are U.S.-centric (accessories like smart lock designed for American doors) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Content/streaming support is unclear — may not play YouTube natively and overall content side is a big question mark — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Reliance on AirPlay/Safari workarounds for some streaming content is uncertain and needs testing — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • No conventional app store and does not run third-party apps natively — won't act like an iPad — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Third-party audio is limited to streaming or iPhone handoff rather than native apps — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition isn't full Face ID; low-light performance is uncertain — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Dependent on developers to add support for streaming and third-party apps; not all apps will be available — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Limited third-party smart home application support could prevent useful integrations (e.g., opening a vacuum cleaning map and selecting rooms) — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Some experiences may be limited by which integrations Apple chooses to support — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about integration with existing third-party devices (notably Ring/Amazon devices); current ecosystem limited to LG and Schneider — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear which third-party apps will be available (lack of detail on supported apps) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Potential compatibility gaps with many existing smart-home devices the user already owns — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • No app store — no on‑device way to download apps; relies on CarPlay‑style passthrough from nearby iPhone/iPad — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Key Siri personal context/features require a paired Apple Intelligence‑capable iPhone or iPad — otherwise you lose personal features — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Home screen faces are shared across users; personalized layouts only available after profile detection — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Very restricted software environment — no app store or third‑party apps (e.g., no native YouTube app) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Not a replacement for an iPad—cannot run full App Store apps and is focused primarily on home/smart-device tasks — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • iPad dashboards can't handle multiple users—the HomeView will change by person but iPad cannot — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad only works with Apple Home (doesn't work with Home Assistant) — limited ecosystem — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Apple's HomeView hardware may limit customization: reportedly only one modular watch face per HomeView and up to nine controls (limiting for large smart homes) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad app must be open for screen to stay awake (limitation when used on always-on iPad) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Limited third-party app support at launch — no native YouTube or Spotify apps (must use Safari for YouTube) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear long-term integration/usage patterns within some families — uncertainty whether all family members will adopt it — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Apple is late to the smart display market — some features rivals already offered (e.g., Echo Show existed since 2017) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about app support and other details at launch (unknown which video apps will be available) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
Value for Money (85)
  • First offering is not very convincing — limited additional value over existing smart displays — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • High starting price ($300) compared with competitors (Nest Hub Max $229, Echo Hub $179) — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted and stand versions cost the same despite differences (wall version lacks woofer and color options) — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Wall adapter and mounting accessories are extra cost (USB-C $60, AC $80, PoE $130) and not included — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Reviewer thinks it's a skip for most people; the product doesn't justify the extra price for most buyers — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • High price / 'Apple tax' — expensive ecosystem and accessories (sensors, thermostats, cameras) add up — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Questions about necessity — many users may not see why it exists — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Raises the question of whether another screen is necessary given existing Apple devices (phone, iPad, MacBook, Watch) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Priced higher than some competitors ($299) — may be a stretch if not already deep in Apple ecosystem — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version is same $300 price but lacks the speaker base (no subwoofers/passive drivers), and does not include cable, power adapter, or wall mount — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Additional costs and complexity for wall mount options: $59 USB-C wall connector (aesthetic issues), $80 hard AC wired mount (requires electrician/legal permitting), or $130 PoE option — overall expensive and annoying installation — Max Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear value compared to an iPad — may not do anything an iPad can't. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • If you already have an iPad, the HomeView is an additional $300 device (not a replacement). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Additional accessories and mounting options are expensive (USB‑C mount $60, AC wired mount $80, PoE base $130) and may require electrician for installation. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Some extra features and accessories feel overpriced; incremental options should cost less than Apple charges. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • If bought in unsupported regions (like Vietnam), there may be no official warranty — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Premium pricing (around 10 million VND / $299) may be considered expensive for some users — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop and wall-mounted versions are the same price ($299) despite the wall version lacking the larger woofer speaker and included base. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Both versions priced the same ($299) despite different included accessories/features (value mismatch) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • At $299, may be too expensive for users already satisfied with Echo Show or Nest Hub unless Apple's integration and privacy justify switching. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • High starting price ($299) — may limit how many people will buy or place multiple around the house — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted pricing and packaging confusion: wall-mounted version is same price but does NOT include the wall mount in the box — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Wall mount options are expensive and sold separately (USB-C mount $60, in-wall AC $80, PoE $130) and PoE not available until early 2027 — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Total cost for wall-mounted setup quickly increases (display + mount + installation), making multiple units expensive — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Confusing pricing decision where the tabletop version with base and the wall version cost the same despite different included accessories — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted configuration is more expensive and offers less value than the tabletop model — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • First-gen nature of the product — a more capable 'Pro' with robotic arm and greater versatility is rumored soon, so buyers may want to wait — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Pro version (robotic arm) would add mechanical complexity and likely higher price — potential reliability/price concerns — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Wall‑mounted model is effectively less (no mount included) but costs the same $299, and mounts are sold separately and can be expensive — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Mount accessories are pricey (example PoE mount $129) and the wall model not discounted despite needing a mount — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • Pricing is surprising/controversial — retails for $299 which some find high — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version is the same base price despite including less (no woofer/stand) — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted unit does not include the actual wall mount; mounting hardware sold separately ($60–$130) — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Overall value questioned — a $300 screen that largely duplicates phone functionality and is more expensive than Google/Amazon competitors — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Perception that Apple is charging wealthier customers more for a lesser (wall) product, which feels unfair or like a 'scam' — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Apple devices (HomePod, smart hub) are expected to be expensive compared to alternatives — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about value — expensive at $300 and feels like a giant Apple Watch without an app store — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version lacks speaker and cords and requires additional installation — extra cost/effort — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • $299 is expensive if the device will only sit showing the time — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version costs the same but the mount is extra (additional expense) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version ships with no power adapter or cable (tabletop includes them) yet costs the same — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Some power accessory options are expensive (e.g., $80 hardwired mount, $130 PoE adapter coming later) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted pricing criticized as poor value given the audio hardware loss compared to the tabletop version — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Dock model adds speakers but both docked and wall-mounted versions cost the same ($300), raising questions about value and where the 'brains' are located. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Price ($300) is steep compared with rival smaller smart displays from Amazon/Nest. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Buying it solely for music or basic tasks (weather) may not be reasonable — best value for users with existing Apple tech and smart devices — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted model priced the same as standard but requires buying the mount separately, adding to cost — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Ad is widely criticized — described as the worst tech ad, obnoxious and unlikable, making the product look pointless. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Product seen as unnecessary — doesn’t solve problems that aren’t already solved by smartphones or conventional tablets. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Overlaps with existing connected‑home and tablet products (Echo/Alexa/tablets), so redundant in the market. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Ad’s depiction of family life is unpleasant and alienating, creating negative associations with the product. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Reviewer finds the product a massive waste of time and questions who it will appeal to. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Price is $300 which may be questionable given limitations — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Comparisons to much cheaper Echo Show (screen too small / overpriced criticism from some users) — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version is perceived as a penalty: it removes the base (no woofer), costs the same as base unit, and requires buying an expensive separate mount/power options — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Additional mandatory costs for wall mount accessories (basic USB-C mount $59; hardwired $79.95; PoE $130) — adds to total price — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Reviewer is not buying the wall version and recommends the base version for better sound — suggests wall version offers worse value — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Premium price ($299) compared to Google and Amazon alternatives — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version does not include the mounting power adapter, which can cost an extra $60–$130 — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • May be a poor value for power users who want more apps and flexibility — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Price/value concerns — may be seen as expensive compared to alternatives — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Overall functionality must justify price given established alternatives from Amazon and Google — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • May arrive late to a market already established by competitors, making adoption harder — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version not cheaper despite lacking a base — pricing feels off — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Realistic wall setup costs more due to mount (approx. $360 before installation) and some mounts require electrician or extra purchases — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Many Apple Home Collection accessories are expensive — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • High repair cost (up to $279 without AppleCare+, close to device price), making replacement sometimes more sensible than repair — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Expensive overall (device plus accessories), and pricier than many third‑party smart displays — heavy ecosystem commitment required to justify purchase — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Questionable need: may duplicate functionality already available on phones or iPads which support more apps — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Could be considered expensive for ‘just a screen on your kitchen counter’ compared with Echo devices — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • $299 price is relatively expensive compared with other smart displays — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Best value only if already invested in Apple's ecosystem; not suitable for Android households — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Wall mount sold separately (additional cost) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • For users who only want basic functions (music, weather, timers), $299 is overkill — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Third‑party accessories are not cheap (accessories from LG/Schneider are expensive) — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Price is higher than many rivals ($299) while competitors have lower prices and larger screens — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Wall mount sold separately and additional mounting options (USB-C, wired, PoE) add extra cost — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Wall model ships with just the screen (no power adapter included) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • High accidental damage repair cost without AppleCare Plus ($279) and AppleCare costs extra annually — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Early impressions mixed — some reviewers say it's a skip for most people — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Висока ціна в Україні — орієнтовно 400–450 євро за смарт‑дисплей (300$ у США) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Сумнівна цінність пристрою: виглядає як красива цифрова фоторамка з додатковими функціями за високий цінник — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Неясно, чи виправдовує ціна відсутність повноцінно працюючої Siri (питання відкрито) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Багато аксесуарів офіційно продаватимуться лише в США, Канаді та Великій Британії — до інших країн дійдуть сірими каналами та за високою ціною — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Збереження історії відео камер вимагає платної підписки iCloud Plus — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Design & Build Quality (50)
  • No battery — must stay plugged in (though uses USB-C) — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Thick black bezels that may be visually unappealing compared to Apple's recent design choices — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Fixed to one spot — not portable like an iPad; moving it requires unplugging and re-powering. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Stand is not adjustable/tiltable — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Hiding cables may be a hassle because they have to be buried in the wall for the wall-mounted option — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Wall version requires an extra-cost wall mount and USB-C power adapter is sold separately (additional accessories/expense) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Tabletop model availability delayed for some colors (shipping delays) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version does not include mounting hardware and may require buying expensive adapters or professional installation (additional costs: $60 USB-C mount, $80 AC adapter, $130 PoE). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Design feels less 'homey' and appears cheaper/unusual—large black bezels, sharp metal base, and aesthetic may not blend into home environments. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Large black bezels and metal base may show smudging and look bad in kitchens over time. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Square design and overall materials (lack of fabric, sharp corners) may make it less appealing than competitors that feel more 'home-friendly'. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted model requires separate purchase of wall-mount accessory — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version requires purchasing a hardwired adapter separately (and PoE adapter coming later) — Michael Caputo · ▶ Watch
  • Name change disappointment (not called HomePod) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Stand version display only tilts up and down (no left/right tilt) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version lacks included power adapter and requires separate wall mount/power purchase — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version incurs additional cost for mounting/power options (approx. $60–$130 for mounts/power solutions) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Wall‑mounted model requires separately purchased mount and power solution. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall mount costs an extra $60 (separate purchase) — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • Physically smaller than expected (surprisingly small in person) — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Hinge does not allow side-to-side movement — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Aesthetic/installation concern: cord hanging from wall-mounted (cord mount) looks bad and may require hiring someone for a clean install — Andru Edwards · ▶ Watch
  • Form factor (small tethered tablet) may limit social interaction and usefulness; a larger wall display might be better. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • No visible power button — hard reset likely requires unplugging the device. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Current version is physically static — limited movement (only slight swivel/angle) making it awkward for true multi-user/shared use — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • The $60 wall-mount option relies on USB‑C and requires a separate power adapter that is not included — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • May become an extra distracting screen in the home (risk of pulling attention away) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Physical placement and power cord could be awkward (5-ft cable; no hidden outlet in most kitchens) — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Home View is not portable — you cannot move it around the house like an iPad. — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version does not include the 30W charger/cable that comes with the tabletop model. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Both versions must be permanently plugged into power (no battery operation) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Chunky quarter-inch bezels around the display — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Confusing and inconsistent power requirements (tabletop needs 30W, wall-mounted workable on 20W; some mounting options cost extra or require hardwiring) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mount requires a separately purchased special mount and device needs constant power (no battery) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Unoriginal and uninspiring — essentially an iPad that can’t be picked up, offers nothing new. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • Not a general-purpose tablet — no built-in battery and cannot be carried around — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Requires constant power (no internal battery) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Leaks' expected iMac G4 aesthetic not fully realized (design less appealing than rumored) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • No swivel; display only tilts up and down so you must physically rotate the unit to change orientation — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • Thick black bezels that may not appeal to everyone — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • No battery — cannot be used as a portable display when unplugged — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Wished for a single model that could be used wall-mounted or freestanding (current separate variants) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Limited color options for wall-mounted model (only two colors) — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Name 'home view' is not particularly loved — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • No official IP rating or splash resistance disclosed — risky to place near sink — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Hardware isn't radically new—could be seen as an iPad-like screen on a speaker (questions about new category) — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Leaving an iPad plugged in 24/7 can cause battery swelling (especially older iPads) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • HomeView placement challenges in kitchen: powering/mounting at island stove area impractical without drilling or visible cabling — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Display tilt only up/down on stand; cannot pan left/right without rotating the whole unit — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • No battery — must stay plugged in (less placement flexibility) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
Smart Assistant Performance (20)
  • No voice recognition/personalization by voice — personal context only when the camera sees you nearby — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Some requests use Private Cloud Compute and Siri AI is launching in beta (potential limitations/immaturity) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Confusing and unclear OS/functionality boundaries—uncertainty about what tasks it can actually perform versus deferring to iPhone/iPad. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about how much functionality is intentionally limited (i.e., will push users to use their phone for many tasks). — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Real-world effectiveness of improved Siri/AI remains to be seen (uncertain performance) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Advanced AI features initially available only in English — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI is only somewhat smarter — not perfect — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Siri currently speaks only English — effectively limited to North American market — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • When asked by voice without recognizing user, plays generic playlists (limited personalization by voice alone) — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • For many regions the product is unnecessary or almost useless until Siri supports more languages — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • No voice-based personal recognition — Siri may not know which user's info to show when asked from a distance — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Concerns about Siri's historical limitations and whether the software/AI experience will be reliable enough — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Siri voice customization is heavily limited (only configurable on certain high‑end devices, only in English) — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Not available in the EU at launch because Siri AI isn't available there — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Siri's real-world improvements are still unproven; if Siri remains poor, the device may feel like an expensive appliance with trust issues — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI launches as an English-only beta (limited language availability and early-stage software) — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Української мови немає — Siri/AI не підтримує українську, тому для більшості функції AI марні — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Нові «розумні» функції Siri AI для HomePod Mini відсутні на старті продажів і будуть додані пізніше — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Щоб колонка враховувала персональний контекст, потрібен актуальний iPhone з підтримкою Apple Intelligence — купувати лише за AI в Україні недоцільно — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Розумний пошук по відео через ШІ вимагає актуального iPhone з підтримкою Apple Intelligence (обмеження доступності функції) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Privacy & Security (17)
  • Facial recognition is not full Face ID (no IR/depth); potential reliability concerns in low light and against spoofing — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • No true Face ID system (less secure) and no infrared, raising questions about operation in the dark — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about facial recognition performance in low light and how quickly it switches between people — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy concern question raised about a camera that recognizes faces in the kitchen (potential unease despite Apple's privacy claims) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Facial recognition logic that checks for a nearby unlocked iOS device may be questionable in practice (privacy/expectation concerns about how 'nearby' is defined). — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Front-facing camera does not support Face ID (only facial recognition) — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Camera uses front-facing camera technology (not Face ID) which may raise security concerns — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Cannot take photos with the device — camera limited to FaceTime/mirror and recognition (privacy trade-off) — Engadget · ▶ Watch
  • No biometric Face ID or Touch ID—face recognition is not at a biometric level, which raises privacy and security concerns when personal info appears. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear behavior around face-checking and who can interact with calls/notifications—risk of others answering or seeing personal items accidentally. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy system has multiple steps (facial recognition plus nearby unlocked device) — may add complexity though intended to be seamless — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy concerns remain despite claims (reliability of private cloud/secure processing to be assessed) — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Apple's privacy walls limit third-party AI agents from accessing data, reducing what outside AI tools can do for you — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Privacy-first approach can hold back pushing AI to its limits (trade-off between capability and privacy) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Contributes to increased screen time and intrusive smart‑home tech; reviewer prefers fewer internet‑connected devices at home. — Computing Forever · ▶ Watch
  • No physical shutter to disable camera/mic (though privacy processing is local) — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Face recognition and centralized access to personal info raise privacy questions in real household scenarios (multiple people talking, pets, noise) despite Apple's privacy claims — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
Display Quality (16)
  • Display likely 60Hz (not clear higher refresh), and overall product may feel gimmicky after initial novelty — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Display may feel small to some (7-inch), though intentional for purpose — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Square display may not be ideal for watching video content—uncertain entertainment experience — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Can't confirm performance of very low brightness in real sleep scenarios (potential small light disturbance) — Katarina Mogus · ▶ Watch
  • Screen is LCD (not OLED) and only up to 500 nits — not top-tier display tech. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Some color options appear muted or too gray/silver-toned to the reviewer — Booredatwork.com · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version has fewer color options (only two) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Screen is only a 7-inch square, smaller than many expect and not ideal for watching video. — Linus Tech Tips · ▶ Watch
  • Display is small (about 6–7 inches) with modest resolution (around 1000x1000) and not particularly high pixel density. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Display maxes out at only ~500 nits—limited peak brightness. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Small 7" display with fairly large black bezels and only 60 Hz refresh rate — THE ROCO · ▶ Watch
  • Screen aspect (not 16:9) may be suboptimal for watching content — questions about content/streaming support — Craig's Tech Talk · ▶ Watch
  • 7-inch display is small compared with competitors (e.g., Amazon Echo Show); larger screen would be more useful in places like the kitchen — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Limited screen size can hinder tasks like following recipes or watching videos while preparing food — Wiz Tech & Gaming · ▶ Watch
  • Surprisingly small screen (7-inch) and tight aspect ratio not ideal for video or users who prefer larger displays — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Smaller screen than some competitors (7-in vs larger Echo Show models) despite higher price — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
Sound Quality (15)
  • Wall-mounted version lacks the base woofer (worse sound), limited colors, and requires buying an adapter separately — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Relatively low maximum volume for its size — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Unknown speaker quality — The Apple Circle · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version loses the woofer and has weaker sound (only 2 drivers), so sound quality is reduced vs stand model. — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version may be less optimal acoustically than the stand version (stand likely more optimal) — iTechLife · ▶ Watch
  • Wall unit likely sounds worse because it lacks the big woofer present on the tabletop model. — Waveform Clips · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version sounds worse because it omits the internal woofer — Cameron Dougherty Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version lacks the stainless steel dome speaker base and heavier woofer, resulting in weaker speakers — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted version has significantly worse audio (only two full-range drivers, no woofer or force-canceling radiators) — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Overall sound not expected to match the full-sized HomePod; wall-mounted likely worst in lineup — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted speaker sound claim not heard in person (uncertainty about real-world performance) — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Wall version loses the base woofer and therefore fuller sound (you may pay more and get less) — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Sound quality called acceptable but maximum volume could be better — Reviory · ▶ Watch
  • Wall‑mounted model is same price but has worse audio (no woofer or passive radiators) and often requires buying mounts and adapters separately — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Wall model lacks the woofer (reduced bass) compared with tabletop model — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
Connectivity & Compatibility (14)
  • Apple smart-home ecosystem is currently smaller than Amazon's and Google's, limiting overall value for serious smart-home enthusiasts — Marques Brownlee · ▶ Watch
  • Uses Wi‑Fi 6E rather than Wi‑Fi 7 (newer Apple devices already have Wi‑Fi 7). — Adam Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • HomeKit and new Home View (and many Apple smart-home products) are not officially sold or supported in some regions (e.g., Vietnam) — Tuấn Ngọc đây! · ▶ Watch
  • Not sold in the EU (not available in Europe) — Bytes by Bobby · ▶ Watch
  • Power over Ethernet option not available at launch (coming later) — SuperSaf · ▶ Watch
  • Not selling in the EU at launch (availability limitation) — The Current Version · ▶ Watch
  • Missing Wi‑Fi 7 (only Wi‑Fi 6E), reviewer wished for more future-proofing — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Not available in the EU at launch — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Tight integration creates strong vendor lock-in — the more your family uses it, the harder it is to leave the Apple ecosystem — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Social friction when leaving iPhone ecosystem (e.g., lack of FaceTime/iMessage features for non-iPhone users) — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • HomePad only works if you're in the Apple Home ecosystem and grant access to home data (privacy/compatibility constraint) — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Siri AI (required for full functionality) is not available in the EU, so Home View can't be bought there — Mark Ellis Reviews · ▶ Watch
  • Not launching in the EU because Siri AI isn't available there yet — Lifey Guy · ▶ Watch
  • Використання HomePod як бездротової колонки для Mac вимагає сучасного Mac з Wi‑Fi 6E (обмеження сумісності) — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Performance & Reliability (14)
  • Potential for the device to become unused/collect dust after initial weeks — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty about how much it will be used in some households (depends on household members, e.g., children without phones) — 9to5Mac · ▶ Watch
  • Reviewer hasn't had hands‑on experience yet, so interface and audio quality impressions are unverified — zollotech · ▶ Watch
  • The speaker hasn't used HomePod minis due to the lack of drop-in feature, so real-world usefulness is unproven for their use case — Eamonn Cottrell · ▶ Watch
  • Many unanswered questions about functionality and real-world use — CNET · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty remains about real-world performance and limitations since the reviewer hadn't used Home View at home yet (some features still to be determined). — Shane Whatley · ▶ Watch
  • Questions about whether Home View is powerful enough relative to price—A18 chip but apparently less capable than Apple TV's chip for some tasks. — Tailosive Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Some features (speed/reliability/security of user switching) need careful real-world testing and verification — PCMag · ▶ Watch
  • Unclear how well microphones handle noisy environments — performance to be determined — Smart Kinetic Digital · ▶ Watch
  • Apple has a history of promising smart features and then delaying them — Leslie Samuel · ▶ Watch
  • Release date is months away (available in November) — not immediately available — Travis MCP · ▶ Watch
  • Accessory rollout is delayed — collection doesn't start rolling out until at least December and some items may not arrive until 2027 — MacRumors · ▶ Watch
  • Uncertainty whether features work as advertised until launch—value depends on real-world performance — Christopher Canada · ▶ Watch
  • Розпізнавання і персоналізація працюють тільки якщо iPhone/iPad в тій самій Wi‑Fi мережі і вже розблокований — сумнівна зручність — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch
Ease of Use (9)
  • Requires a compatible iPhone or iPad running version 27.2 or later for setup. — I Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Requires an iPhone on the latest iOS (likely iOS 27/27.2) to set up — no Android setup support. — Matt Talks Tech · ▶ Watch
  • Requires fairly recent iPhone or iPad (iOS/iPadOS 27.2+) — iPhone 11 or newer or iPad 9th gen or newer to use — ZONEofTECH · ▶ Watch
  • Software feels like a confusing mix of WatchOS, CarPlay and iPad; may take users time to figure out — The Tech Chap · ▶ Watch
  • Running an iPad as a dashboard requires it to be plugged in always or managed charging, causing practicality issues — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Using an iPad requires managing screen on/off states; HomeView is expected to be smarter about wake/display — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Wall-mounted HomeView may be too far from cooking area to read recipes or interact comfortably — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Some kitchen locations (corner near toaster oven) would be obstructed or not visible for recipes/timers — Stephen Robles · ▶ Watch
  • Функція персоналізованих повідомлень вимагає розблокованого телефону — сумнівна логіка і користь — Алекс Tech · ▶ Watch

Review sources

Frequently asked questions

Is the Apple HomeView worth buying?

Based on 43 independent YouTube reviews, the Apple HomeView scores 3.4/5 with 520 positive and 335 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #2 in the Smart Displays category.

What do reviewers like most about the Apple HomeView?

The most praised aspects are features & functionality, design & build quality, smart assistant performance — Features & Functionality (200 mentions), Design & Build Quality (74 mentions), Smart Assistant Performance (64 mentions).

What are the most common complaints about the Apple HomeView?

Reviewers most frequently criticize features & functionality, value for money — Features & Functionality (95 mentions), Value for Money (85 mentions).

Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!