RANKING

Rank 15 out of 29 Summarized in this category Rankings based on: • Pros-to-cons ratio • Number of reviews • Category average

Mandragora

Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree

Name: Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree
Brand: Mandragora

around $18

All prices are estimates and may vary from actual prices.

262 Pros

73%
18 reviews (3h 6m)

95 Cons

Venture into the grim, hand-painted world of Faelduum in *Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree*, an ambitious indie RPG that merges punishing Soulslike combat with sprawling Metroidvania exploration. Wrapped in a stunning watercolor art style and featuring a fully voice-acted narrative, this dark fantasy adventure offers a deep and rewarding expe...

Summary of pros and cons from human reviewers, put together by AI

70%

180 vs 76

Gameplay

79%

19 vs 5

Story & Narrative

80%

12 vs 3

Content & Value

94%

15 vs 1

Graphics & Visuals

77%

10 vs 3

Sound & Music

Reviewer verdict

Across 18 YouTube reviews, the Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree earns an Index score of 3.9/5, ranking #15 among Indie Games. Reviewers most often praise its gameplay, story & narrative, graphics & visuals, while the most common criticisms concern gameplay, story & narrative.

Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree is widely praised for its deep, satisfying gameplay loop that blends Soulslike combat with Metroidvania exploration; this is the most cited strength (174 mentions) across reviewers. Critics consistently applaud the hefty, tactical combat, expansive multiclass talent trees and buildcrafting, robust crafting/merchant systems, and large, hand‑painted interconnected world full of secrets and biomes. Many reviewers also highlight quality-of-life staples that enhance play—early fast travel, plentiful save points, extensive accessibility sliders, and strong voice acting and soundtrack—adding to its replayability and value. Overall consensus frames it as a standout indie Soulsvania with rich customization, frequent updates, and high production polish for its scope.

Most criticisms concentrate on gameplay friction and pacing issues (76 mentions), including punishing fall damage, occasional tedious backtracking or long travel between NPCs (mitigated in updates), and grindy or awkward crafting and resource systems like Entropy Rifts and entropic essence. Reviewers also note a steep, sometimes overwhelming learning curve from massive skill trees and complex stats that can frustrate new players, plus uneven boss variety and repeated enemy/reskin complaints. A minority mention technical or presentation issues—frequent loading screens, some audio mixing inconsistencies, and non‑robust control/customization options—while a few feel story pacing and writing can be uneven.

Analysis based on 18 YouTube reviews (3h 6m of video) with 262 pros and 95 cons extracted.

Pros (262)

Gameplay (180)

Ability to farm enemies and level up if stuck ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 3:30
Multiple character classes and customization options ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 3:44
Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree is a really deep RPG with class choices and many gameplay options. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 0:08
Added a bonfire (witch stone) before the final boss, reducing frustrating travel time. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 1:23
Shortcut introduced between Ree and Ursa to reduce long travel times between important NPCs. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 2:07
Stamina won't deplete in safe zones, improving gameplay experience. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 3:29
Essence recovery before boss fights added, making it easier to prepare. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 3:37
Roseline sells infinite food, helping with resource management. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 3:56
Lower crafting level for major mana potions allows earlier access. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 4:15
New magic runestones added with different damage and scaling effects. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 4:23
Weapon and stamina stagger rebalancing to make more weapons viable. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 4:42
Shops and crafting prices lowered, making progression easier. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 5:14
Fall damage adjusted, reducing frustration from deaths by falling. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 5:58
The game combines RPG elements with Metroidvania style progression in a satisfying way. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 6:39
Includes adjustable difficulty sliders for enemy damage, health, etc., allowing customization of challenge. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 1:28
Features a character creator with multiple classes and talent trees for diverse play styles. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 1:47
Ability to equip two sets of gear and swap between them ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 4:51
Talent trees replace traditional stat upgrades, offering ability customization and build variety. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 2:16
Includes crafting system with artisans like blacksmiths to create gear from collected materials. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 4:22
Wide variety of combat styles and character classes to choose from, allowing for diverse gameplay. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 3:53
Massive skill trees offering many options for character build customization. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 5:13
The game offers a significant challenge, providing satisfying and engaging combat. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 5:46
Itemization system is familiar and robust, with different gear rarities and crafting options. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 7:20
Character progression and equipment scaling are well implemented, enhancing the gameplay loop. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 7:51
Combines different systems and inspirations from various genres into a satisfying overall experience. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 8:32
Players can blend classes after reaching level 25 to create custom builds, offering flexibility in gameplay. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 3:00
The map is large and the game features a helpful completion percentage indicator for exploration. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 3:46
The poison aspect and poison blades combat style are enjoyable and well-implemented. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 5:08
There is a wide variety of weapons, armor, and rings to collect and craft. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 5:14
The game tracks detailed player stats and gear, which is a nice feature for completionists. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 5:24
Players can find and pet cats in the game, adding charm and personality. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 5:43
Combat is smooth and the game is accessible to average gamers. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 6:14
There are multiple vendors at the base for upgrading and crafting gear, enhancing gameplay depth. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 6:26
Fast travel and save points are available, improving convenience. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 8:48
The game includes a massive world with genre staples like a map, huge skill tree, and leveling system. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:45
Combat has a satisfying Soulslike feel with nice speed and fluidity, making encounters fun and rewarding. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 2:19
The flame weaver class allows for spell casting and single-handed weapon wielding, providing enjoyable combat variety. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 2:22
The game features a surprising amount of platforming with diverse environments to explore and secret treasures. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 2:47
Villages allow players to replenish inventory, upgrade weapons, and take on additional quests, fulfilling RPG basics well. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 3:00
Compared to many dark RPGs with souls-like elements, Mandreora feels reasonably manageable, especially in early stages. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 3:10
Bosses are tough but fair, checkpoints are plentiful, and accessibility options allow tuning difficulty. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 3:18
Accessibility options include toning down enemy damage and adjusting skill points required for magic, helping players who struggle with the genre. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 3:22
Character customization allows choosing faces, hairstyles, skin colors, and voices, providing some degree of personalization. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:19
Six classes are available, ranging from sword wielding vanguard to magical flame weaver, offering variety in play styles. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:33
Incredibly fun gameplay loop combining Metroidvania and Souls-inspired action combat ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 1:25
Well-designed character design and skill trees with multiclassing options ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 1:36
Skill trees promote experimentation, flexibility, and creativity with respec options ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 2:56
Incredibly fun and cool skills that complement the different schools of skill trees ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 3:28
Blends deep character customization, Metroidvania style exploration, and beautiful handpainted art style with intense combat. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 0:04
Allows players to choose from six powerful starting classes, each with unique play styles, weapons, abilities, and talent trees. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 0:22
Skill-driven combat with brutal boss battles where every strike matters. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 0:40
At level 25, players can branch out into other class skill trees, mixing and matching abilities and passives to create unique builds. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 0:49
Sprawling interconnected Gothic world with multiple nonlinear paths and hidden secrets. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 1:20
Vanguard class has highest starting health and equip load, allowing use of heavy weapons and armor, plus adrenaline-based combat abilities. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 2:47
Flame Weaver class offers a mix of physical and magic damage, powerful and cost-effective fire spells, and versatile armor options. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 4:47
Spellbinder class has high mana pool, powerful chaos magic with long-range and high damage spells, and complex but rewarding gameplay. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 7:55
Nightshade class specializes in swift movements, dual wield daggers, combo points system, and poison-based damage with unique combat loops. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 10:07
Wild Warden class combines nature-based magic with one-handed weapons, has strong offensive and defensive skills, and thematic talent tree. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 12:43
Vindicator class offers a paladin-like playstyle with melee and ranged attacks, healing magic, and self-sustain abilities. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 15:10
Ability to combine skills from all six classes after level 25 for highly customizable builds. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 17:00
Das Spiel bietet sechs Klassen mit unterschiedlichen Fähigkeiten und ermöglicht ab Stufe 25 den Zugriff auf alle Klassen-Skilltrees und Spezialfähigkeiten, was viel Flexibilität bietet. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 1:08
Die Kämpfe sind taktisch, mit einem vergleichsweise niedrigen Tempo, bei dem das Studieren des Gegnerverhaltens und das richtige Timing der Ausweichrolle entscheidend sind. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 2:14
Die Ausweichrolle ist besonders wichtig und erlaubt es, praktisch durch alle Gegner und Projektile ohne Schaden zu rollen, wenn sie im richtigen Moment ausgeführt wird. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 2:45
Die Bosskämpfe sind herausfordernd und erfordern präzises Ausweichen und Timing, was ein befriedigendes Kampferlebnis bietet. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 3:19
Das Kampfsystem fühlt sich wie ein Tanz an, bei dem man schnell ein gutes Gefühl für die richtige Abfolge von Schlägen und Ausweichmanövern bekommt, was gegen Standardgegner effektiv macht. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 3:56
Das Spiel bietet verschiedene Hilfsmittel wie Schleifsteine und Mahlzeiten für temporäre Boni sowie Schwierigkeitsanpassungen, die das Spiel auch für weniger erfahrene Spieler zugänglich machen. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 4:28
Neben Kämpfen gibt es ein Basislager mit Handwerkern und Händlern, die bessere Ausrüstung und Hilfsmittel herstellen können, sowie kleinere Plattformerpassagen und Erkundungselemente. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 5:05
Die Metroidvania-Elemente sind zwar nicht stark ausgeprägt, aber es gibt Gadgets wie Greifhaken und Aktionen zum Durchbrechen des Bodens, die in fester Reihenfolge freigeschaltet werden. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 5:31
Die Entwickler haben die dungeonartigen Umgebungen gut gestaltet, sodass das Erkunden der hintersten Ecken belohnt wird. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 6:10
Das Spiel unterstützt die Wegfindung mit Karten und Zielmarkern für Quests, sodass man nicht blind suchen muss. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 6:25
Nonlinear game world with freedom to explore and side quests ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 1:11
Interconnected areas with maps that reveal zones and shortcuts for smoother navigation ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 1:38
Lots of secret and hidden areas to uncover ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 2:08
Skill-based combat with emphasis on learning enemy timings and dodging/blocking ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 2:31
Platforming is present but not overly challenging or punishing ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 2:38
Wide variety of enemies and bosses with mechanics to learn ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 2:55
Gear has weight, speed, stagger, stamina cost, and damage attributes affecting gameplay ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 5:10
Armor grants poise and other stats like armor and spirit defense ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 5:37
Four ring slots with unique effects and no double stacking ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 6:06
Up to 10 consumables can be equipped and cycled through ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 6:16
Equip load affects movement speed and evasion, adding strategic depth ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 6:38
Detailed talent trees for each class with meaningful build choices ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 7:50
Interesting active skills like chaos beam and shotgun attack with different tactical uses ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 10:57
Multiple NPCs in town offering crafting, map unlocking, and other services ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 11:19
Crafting system includes armor kits, potions, weapons, jewelry, and runestones for enchantments ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 11:27
Map fragments unlock clearer world maps, encouraging exploration ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 13:34
Overall very enjoyable game with anticipation to finish and explore more ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 15:03
The game offers a flexible multiclassing system allowing for crazy combinations and synergies between classes like pyromancer and warrior. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 0:54
There is a way to respec your character at the altar of power, allowing you to retalent and adjust your build if needed. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 0:36
The skill tree is simpler and less overwhelming compared to other games with large skill trees like Path of Exile. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 0:22
Attributes and scaling mechanics are explained clearly, helping players understand how to optimize their builds. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 1:27
The game includes build-altering nodes that significantly change gameplay, such as the Phoenix node that allows resuscitation with 50% health. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 5:21
The game rewards strategic planning in choosing paths on the skill tree, with distinct sides favoring melee or caster builds. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 5:57
Weapon scaling with stats is well implemented, allowing players to maximize damage by matching weapons with their attribute investments. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 3:09
The game supports diverse playstyles, from melee warriors to mana-based casters, with appropriate nodes and scaling for each. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 7:04
Fell in love with the Souls-like Metroidvania gameplay again. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 0:47
Combat is up close and personal with a variety of magic-based classes. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 1:14
Variety of classes including sword and board vanguard and four magic classes with different magic types. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 0:59
Campaign sends you through a variety of environments like swamps, forests, vampire castles, and dungeons. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 2:06
You build a caravan of NPCs around the witch tree, a safe place for buying gear, crafting, and growing seeds. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 2:13
Multiple NPCs provide services like blacksmith, tailor, cook, gold worker, and enchanter. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 2:19
Skills for each class can be learned or purchased and you can equip any combination of five skills. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 2:46
Crafting system allows making potions, oils, tinctures, and meals for buffs. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:07
Movement is a joy with traversal options like grappling hook and double jump unlocking new areas. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:10
Use of magical witch lantern to explore a dangerous dark space between worlds adds depth. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:17
Massive campaign with alternate routes, multiple classes, secrets, hidden areas, and optional bosses. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:48
Difficulty sliders allow reducing enemy health and damage by 30%. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 5:01
Delivers everything a fan of 2D action adventure or Metroidvania genre could want. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 5:08
The game maintains focus on the main story without overwhelming side tasks, making exploration enjoyable and necessary. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 2:11
Five main weapon types with variations that scale with different attributes, allowing for diverse builds and playstyles. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 2:36
Good variety of armor sets, attachments, potions, and gear that enhance character stats and weapons. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 2:54
Well-balanced sense of progression and variety of monsters and challenging bosses. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 3:03
Six different classes to choose from, each with unique attributes and playstyles. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 3:16
Extensive and intricate talent tree system that allows customization and skill point allocation. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 3:43
Secret areas accessed through portals provide new bosses, materials, and story progression opportunities. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 4:24
Good level design with a sense of discovery and useful map markers and fast travel to ease backtracking. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 5:24
Additional traversal abilities like double jumps, gliding, and grappling hook add variety without oversaturating gameplay. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 6:13
Combat is fun and skill-based, combining elements reminiscent of The Witcher 3 and Dark Souls in 2D form. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 7:35
Difficulty can be adjusted for a smoother experience if the game becomes too frustrating. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 8:48
NPC at campsite provides useful information on enemy weaknesses to aid combat strategy. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 9:25
In the realm of 2D platforming Soulslikes, Mandragora reigns supreme, an absolute triumph. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 0:28
Brutally challenging yet impeccably fair gameplay with relentless AI and crowd control challenges. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 3:07
Difficulty sliders allow for a more casual experience, making the game accessible to all players. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 3:38
Gameplay is pure fun, refined to perfection, the pinnacle of 2D Soulslike gameplay. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 4:40
Progression system is a revelation with a mini Path of Exile style skill tree and multiclassing. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 5:18
Diverse builds, multiclassing, resistant types, poise, armor, permanent upgrades, and loot crafting. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 6:04
NPCs are purposeful, offering upgrades, items, or side quests without wasting time. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 6:50
Enemy variety is vast and aggressive, keeping players on edge non-stop. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 6:55
Highly engaging gameplay that kept the reviewer playing for 11 hours straight. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 7:50
Freedom of movement and customization within the game is enjoyable, allowing players to build and respec classes as they see fit. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 1:33
There is a good variety of weapons and vendors in the main hub that contribute to build customization. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 2:40
Accessibility options with sliders to adjust enemy health, damage, and stamina usage make the game approachable for different skill levels. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 3:43
The accessibility sliders helped the reviewer get through the game and are a great addition for players of varying skill. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 4:23
The game has received updates reducing fall damage and stamina depletion in safe zones, improving gameplay experience. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 10:20
Overall, the reviewer found Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree to be a fun Soulslike game with Metroidvania elements and one of their favorite games of the year. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 11:20
The game offers relatively challenging combat, interesting boss design, and a large variety of weapons and gear. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 1:09
It features a surprisingly in-depth skill tree reminiscent of Path of Exile, allowing solid character customization. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 1:23
The skill tree is interconnected in a smart way, providing versatility in character builds. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 2:10
The crafting system is extensive with over 30 armor sets, 25 ring recipes, and many gear options found or sold in the world. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 3:03
There are multiple vendors in the camp, each with unique offerings and upgradeable through crafting relevant items. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 3:19
The combination of skill tree and crafting allows for unique character builds that feel different from others. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 3:40
Metroidvania elements like movement tools (grappling hook, double jump) allow exploration of previously inaccessible areas. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 4:10
The map provides good information to help with exploration and backtracking. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 4:44
Soulslike combat is handled well with fair, telegraphed enemy attacks that can be blocked or dodged. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 5:28
Enemies can drop their own gear including weapons, allowing players to farm specific sets to suit their build. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 5:50
Overall, the game is a solid title from a small indie studio with high quality and enjoyable gameplay. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 9:26
Mandragora is a thrilling mix of Soulslike challenge and Metroidvania exploration with deep RPG mechanics and intense combat. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:02
Includes powerful bosses, intricate crafting, and unique NPCs enhancing the experience. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:13
Offers diverse environments like eerie forests, treacherous swamps, and scorching deserts with unexpected elements. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:38
Six classes available, each with unique play styles, including Vanguard, Spellbinder, and Nightshade. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:46
Vanguard class offers a brutal melee powerhouse experience with resource management for adrenaline and stamina. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:57
Weapon variety allows different play styles: one-handed with shield, tower shield tanking, or two-handed devastation. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 1:14
Spellbinder class focuses on powerful chaos magic spells, offering a strong but fragile caster archetype. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 1:32
Nightshade class excels in swift, deadly assassin style combat with poison and debuffs, ideal for build customization. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 1:50
Players can respec their characters and talent trees, allowing flexible and creative hybrid builds. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 2:08
Talent trees offer diverse upgrades including offense, defense, utility, and powerful passive abilities. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 2:27
Gear progression is deep with over 350 items and 110 consumables, allowing tailored builds. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 2:52
Equipment affects attack speed, stamina consumption, and special effects, enhancing combat customization. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 3:14
Crafting system is integral, with materials from enemy drops and treasure chests, plus enchanting options. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 3:23
Multiple damage types with distinct effects and scaling, requiring strategic stat investment. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 3:41
NPCs play a significant role with seven artisan vendors specializing in different crafting areas. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 4:15
Artisans level up and upgrading their tents/workstations unlocks more powerful recipes and perks. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 4:47
Overall blend of intense combat, rich exploration, and deep customization makes it a must-play for Soulslike and Metroidvania fans. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 5:01
The land of Faelduum is a magnificently vast and wondrous place with many biomes that are organically interconnected and each exudes its own unique ambience. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 1:46
The world is packed with a litany of secrets and collectibles to uncover, adding depth and making exploration rewarding. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 2:43
The crafting system is engaging with merchants that can be upgraded to craft more powerful items and lower prices, though not mandatory to enjoy the game. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 4:39
Exploration is a blast with a massive map, ability-gated exploration, backtracking, and a very efficient map overview design including manual markers and automatic marking of collectibles. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 6:25
The fast-travel system is incredible and available early, allowing teleportation between activated save points instantly. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 7:37
Combat is the fundamental focus and is hefty, deliberate, tactical, and satisfying, rewarding enemy observation, patience, and exploiting openings. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 8:38
The game offers six different classes with varied gameplay approaches, allowing player choice and customization. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 8:48
The skill tree system allows leveling up and multiclassing for passive benefits and special perks, with the ability to refund skill points. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 10:32
Boss fights are fun, challenging, balanced, and fair, with each defeat providing knowledge to improve chances on the next attempt. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 12:18
The game’s default difficulty is quite challenging with harder than average boss battles and enemies requiring keen observation and reflexes, but accessibility options allow tailoring difficulty. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 13:31
The crafting system and merchant upgrades are not mandatory and can be enjoyed optionally, with materials and gold readily available through exploration and merchants. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 16:00
Glimmer of potential in its combat ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 0:28
Deep RPG options like six interesting character classes, dense skill trees, and in-depth equipment and crafting systems ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 0:54
Skill trees and RPG mechanics offer neat options and customization ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 4:47
Ability to cross-pollinate skill trees to create well-rounded builds ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 5:15
Buildcrafting depth with loot finding, crafting, and runic enchantments ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 5:36
Platforming and secret hunting provide minor breaks between combat ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 5:51

Story & Narrative (19)

Interesting art style and narrative, with involvement of developer Brian Mitsoda in story development. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 5:01
The game offers a dark and compelling environment with a story that subverts expectations. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 1:53
The story is good and fits well with the game's scope and achievements. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 8:59
Story is told through beautiful handpainted cutscenes that look truly haunting, accompanied by impressive voice acting. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:54
There is a tremendous amount of dialogue with various choices affecting characters and quests. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 2:08
Fully voice-acted storyline with multiple endings crafted by renowned writer Brian Moda. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 1:12
Memorable characters with tons of voice acting and great dialogue ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 0:54
Decent story with interesting twists about witches and the world. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 1:27
NPCs also offer backstory and context for the world. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 2:37
The story has a powerful opening with distinct style, great dialogue, and intense music. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 1:43
Interesting and relevant characters that you recruit to the witch tree campsite for crafting and upgrading. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 1:50
Dark, grim, and immersive setting with a fitting ambiance for the genre. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 5:52
The story has surprising twists and depth with excellent writing and cinematics. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 1:09
The story has an interesting twist towards the end and explores themes of good and evil, setting up for future content. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 3:17
The world of Mandragora is rich with secrets, quirky NPCs, grotesque enemies, and tough moral dilemmas. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:28
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree has a fantastic job of fleshing out the world’s deep lore in nostalgically familiar ways that make every nook and cranny feel meaningful. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 1:03
The world is populated by incredibly interesting and eccentric characters that are fully voiced with masterful competence and rendered in beautiful painterly strokes. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 1:13
Interesting and creepy world setting with dark fantasy elements ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 2:20
Great characters to meet, like the unhinged jewel collector Ursa ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 2:34

Graphics & Visuals (15)

The game has a really cool design and art style. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 0:13
Visual enhancements and more clear, visible player and enemy effects. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 3:02
The painted style of cutscenes with gorgeous moving portrait art feels truly unique. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 2:01
The game has stunning art direction, smooth combat, and a haunting soundtrack featuring dark choir accompaniment. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 3:34
Gorgeous, amazing 2.5D watercolor hand painted art style ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 1:06
Mandragora ist eine ziemliche Indie-Perle mit atmosphärischem Mittelalter-Fantasy-Setting und einem einzigartigen Grafikstil, der klassische Polygon-Grafik mit gezeichneten Elementen kombiniert und an ein Gemälde erinnert. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 0:23
Beautiful handpainted world with a great visual style ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 0:49
Visually arresting with effective lighting and cartoony characters. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:34
Unique and impressive art style with excellent voice acting and narration enhances immersion. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 5:00
Visuals are a masterpiece with around 15 distinct biomes and phenomenal dark oppressive dungeons. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 3:57
Colors and contrast are perfectly balanced, ensuring attack patterns and spells are always visible. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 4:14
The art is incredible with beautiful hand-painted character artwork and impressive foregrounds and backgrounds. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 0:47
The game looks great on both Steam Deck and PC, with visuals popping on higher-end PCs. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 1:15
The game features a stunning 2.5D world with rewarding exploration and gameplay. ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED @ 0:06
Mandragora’s artistic approach to presentation is among the best seen in the genre, with phenomenal graphics and ridiculous attention to detail making every image worthy of being framed in an art museum. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 1:28

Replayability (13)

New game plus mode coming soon, adding replayability. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 6:15
Potential for unique builds by mixing classes and talent trees, enhancing replayability. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 5:58
The game offers a long playtime, with one playthrough taking about 80 hours for 99% completion. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 2:25
Mandreora: Whispers of the Witch Tree features over 40 hours of gameplay with tons of quests, bosses, and baddies to take on. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:39
Demo is highly engaging and replayable, keeping the player hooked for hours ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 2:00
About 12 hours of preview build gameplay with lots of exploration and side content ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 1:24
Preview build offered a good eight hours of gameplay with three different classes and secrets. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 0:30
Full game includes other three classes unlocked and additions like a character-centric stat tracker and improved map. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 0:42
Replayability is high due to multiple builds and classes allowing different playthroughs. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 11:15
Massive Metroid Vania with exceptional replay value and about 30 hours for a single playthrough. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 2:32
Replay value is huge and the game is a masterpiece and the year's biggest surprise. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 7:57
New areas, more content, and a future new game plus mode have been added, showing ongoing developer support. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 11:04
The game offers about 27 hours of gameplay with 99% completion and 55 out of 58 quests completed, providing good value for its price. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 14:11

Content & Value (12)

New content added including Forsaken Man, new secret chamber, Brave Castle, and a new area. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 1:02
Public demo available to try out character creation, bosses, and gameplay. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 1:12
Available on multiple platforms (PC, PS5, Xbox Series), making it accessible to many players. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 1:05
The game has a lot of content including combat, skill trees, vendors, crafting, boss fights, exploration, hidden stuff, and hidden bosses. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 2:42
The game is available on multiple platforms including Switch, Steam, PC, Xbox, and PlayStation. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 9:15
The Kickstarter campaign was successful and the reviewer is proud to have backed the game. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 7:24
Das vielfältige Gameplay, der gelungene Grafikstil und die Kämpfe gefallen sehr gut und bieten viel Spielspaß trotz Indie-Budget. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 7:03
Mandragora muss sich in Bezug auf Spielspaß nicht hinter vergleichbaren Titeln wie Prince of Persia oder The Lost Crown verstecken und ist eine klare Empfehlung für actionlastige Sidescroller mit Dark Souls-Elementen. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 7:20
The game is polished, well-designed, and shows care from the developers. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 10:58
Good value at a $40 price point for RPG fans. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 11:32
Overall rating of 9.3 out of 10, considered the best 2D Soulslike and a top 10 Metroidvania. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 7:31
Overall, the game is a visual and auditory delight and a fantastic soulsvania experience deserving a prominent position in a game library. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 17:35

Sound & Music (10)

Voice acting and character visuals during cutscenes are on point and add to the experience. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 4:03
The game has a great soundtrack and good humor. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 7:44
Really solid soundtrack with enjoyable music ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 1:20
Great soundtrack composed by Christos Antonio ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 1:03
Great musical score that evokes ambience without being overbearing. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:43
The game features stellar cinematics with excellent voice acting and a top-notch atmosphere. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 1:35
Fully voice acted with excellent performances and crisp, impactful sound effects. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 7:05
The game features a good amount of voice acting from main and side characters, enhancing the story experience. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 3:07
The game is well voice acted with a top-tier story and good music. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 8:56
The game’s soundtrack features some of the most epic melodies composed by Christos Antoniou, enhancing the experience and even giving the reviewer goosebumps. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 2:15

Originality & Innovation (7)

Mixes sidescrolling with Soulslike elements and Metroidvania style, creating a unique gameplay blend. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 0:34
Mandragora smoothly blends multiple genres into one complete package. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 0:05
It provides a refreshing take on the Metroidvania genre with a lot to love for ARPG fans. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 2:08
Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree is a dark fantasy 2D sidescroller RPG game that provides a unique experience and is considered a hidden gem. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 1:10
Mandraora is a bold new entry in a Metroid Vania Soulslike genre, leaning heavily into its Soulslike roots. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 0:06
The game feels like a spiritual successor to Sultan Century but surpasses it in every possible way. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 0:21
Mandreora blends Metroidvania style gameplay with Soulslike combat, creating an interesting mix not often seen. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 0:26

Controls & User Interface (3)

Beim Rasten öffnet sich automatisch das passende Menüfenster für Stufenaufstiege, Skillpunkte oder Schnellreise, was den Spielfluss verbessert. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 6:39
The game runs smoothly on both gamepad and mouse/keyboard. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 1:57
World map and UI are among the best in the genre, clear, beautiful, and smooth with custom pins. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 4:21

Performance & Stability (2)

No crashes, bugs, glitches, or stutters; controls are tight and responsive. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 1:49
Loading screens are frequent but quick; stability is remarkable for a new release. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 2:22

Overall (1)

The game has a lot of potential and is considered a hidden gem. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 6:54

Cons (95)

Gameplay (76)

The game is not perfect and has some shortcomings. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 0:36
The Entropy Rifts were not enjoyable and felt bland to the reviewer. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 17:22
Previously, the bonfire before the final boss was very far, requiring a painful minute-long elevator travel. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 1:39
Traveling between NPCs like Ree and Ursa was very long and tedious before the shortcut was added. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 2:30
Some crafting and shop leveling felt unrewarding and was done just for the sake of leveling up. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 5:18
Fall damage caused many frustrating deaths. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! @ 5:58
Fall damage is very punishing, with small drops causing significant health loss. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 2:53
Combat in the demo feels basic and not very engaging, possibly due to early demo limitations. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 4:35
The game can be overwhelming at first due to the massive skill trees and complexity. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 5:18
Some bosses, like the first major werewolf boss, can be very challenging and frustrating. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, De @ 6:05
The final boss fight was a bit disappointing and rough, especially for the assassin class. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 4:54
The assassin class is very squishy and challenging to play initially, requiring time to find the right perks and skills. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 3:17
Some bosses are fought multiple times with variants, which may feel repetitive. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 4:46
There are repeating enemies in certain areas, which might reduce variety. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 6:46
The game can cause some deep-rooted gaming trauma due to its dark fantasy and soulslike elements, intimidating less skilled players. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 0:05
Entropic essence system uses a very limited and rare resource that is hard to collect ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 3:56
No way to respec or experiment with upgrades using entropic essence, killing motivation ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 4:13
Crafting system experience gain is very low, making leveling up craftsmen slow ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 6:15
Blueprint level restrictions delay crafting powerful weapons, reducing their usefulness ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 6:28
High resource requirements for crafting cause excessive repetitive grinding ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 7:33
Both entropic essence and crafting systems have obtuse flaws that discourage engagement ▶ Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique @ 8:35
Vanguard class has fewer ranged and magic options, requiring mastery of melee combat and boss mechanics. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 4:13
Flame Weaver class is mana intensive, requiring careful management of mana potions and items. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 7:02
Spellbinder class has low health and stamina, making it fragile and requiring careful avoidance of damage. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 8:05
Spellbinder's close-range skill has shorter range than preferred. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 8:58
Nightshade class has lower health and equip load, forcing use of light armor and reliance on speed and mobility. ▶ How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers O @ 11:01
Die Skilltrees sind etwas unübersichtlich und könnten besser gestaltet sein. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 7:03
Die Metroidvania-Elemente sind nicht sehr stark ausgeprägt und die Gadgets werden in fester Reihenfolge freigeschaltet, was die Erkundungsmöglichkeiten einschränkt. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 5:27
Town layout requires running far and wide to access different NPCs, which can be inconvenient ▶ I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) @ 15:22
The stats and build system can be very daunting and confusing, especially for new players. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 0:10
If you do not know how to build your character properly, some choices in the skill tree could go sour. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 0:33
The need to carefully understand the attributes and scaling before committing to a build can be overwhelming. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 1:21
The skill tree requires commitment to one side or the other, limiting flexibility once chosen. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 6:03
The game is simplified compared to other similar games, which might not satisfy players looking for deeper complexity. ▶ Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best B @ 8:26
Early game has a resource problem with mana potions being hard to come by and cheap potions nearly useless. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:03
Mages burn through mana quickly and talent tree boosts don't help much. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:18
Many stats and attributes to balance making it complex. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:26
Equip load limits movement unless playing Vanguard, making builds tricky. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:35
Took until level 40 to feel comfortable with build on flame weaver class. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:41
Multiclassing dilutes original class making minmaxing harder. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:51
Enemies only respawn when resting or dying, which can be frustrating. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 3:57
Difficulty feels occasionally skewed despite sliders to reduce enemy health and damage. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 4:59
Some bosses and enemies can be frustratingly difficult and poorly designed, leading to impossible situations. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 7:58
Difficulty spikes can make even weaker enemies unnecessarily challenging, causing frustration. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 8:24
Enemies are relentless and dying twice without collecting essence results in losing it all, requiring constant caution. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 8:36
Some boss battles become repetitive with reused enemies and attack patterns. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 8:56
Most active skills for the Vindicator class were not enjoyable or effective, leading to stale combat. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 9:40
The game has a steep learning curve and is not easy to jump into, especially for newcomers to the genre. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 6:56
Backtracking is required as some areas are initially inaccessible, though mitigated by map markers and fast travel. ▶ Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? @ 5:29
The slower pace and high difficulty confused Metroidvania fans expecting something faster. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 8:26
Fall damage was initially too punishing and disliked by the reviewer. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 1:36
Some abilities are only obtained late in the game and could have been better spaced out. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 1:49
Repetitive boss designs with many bosses being reskins with the same attack patterns. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 7:00
The final boss was less interesting than expected and felt more like a bullet hell mechanic rather than a traditional boss fight. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 8:49
Having to run between key NPCs was tedious before a portal was added in a recent update. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 10:00
There is a lot of backtracking required, which is standard for the genre but can be tedious. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 4:33
Some bonfires are spaced too far apart, making certain zones frustrating due to long death runs. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 5:16
Bosses that spawn many ads can be overwhelming, especially for early game caster builds lacking AoE. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 6:21
Death runs to bosses can be long and frustrating with many mobs and one-shot mechanics on the way. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 7:03
Entropy areas are visually hard to navigate, with disappearing platforms and poor visibility causing frequent falls and deaths. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 7:41
The realm of Entropy is bland and not very enjoyable to explore, despite upgrades making traversal easier. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 8:14
The reviewer felt no incentive to switch combat approaches or equipment due to the strength and efficiency of their build, wishing for enemies with specific weaknesses and immunities to encourage variety. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 11:46
Some bosses required a bit of a trek back after dying due to save points being farther than expected, leading to tedium. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 13:22
Some complaints exist about the extensive need for lockpicks for exploration, though the reviewer did not experience shortage due to a merchant selling them. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 15:13
The crafting system can feel grindy if trying to max out merchant levels, requiring some grinding despite being optional. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 16:00
Some save points were inconveniently far from their respective bosses, causing frustration. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 17:28
Game is unfocused and spread woefully thin across many mechanics ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 0:11
Combat is shallow with repetitious enemies and easily evaded attacks ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 0:30
Enemies have obvious windup animations and are mostly pushover ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 3:27
Boss fights are repetitive with few unique attacks and feel like annoyances ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 3:48
Dying is often due to impatience and tedious enemy encounters rather than challenge ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 4:15
Combat encounters are mostly bland and repetitive ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 4:41
Platforming upgrades are spread too far apart and not enticing to obtain ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 6:32
Backtracking becomes monotonous due to shallow map and tedious combat ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 6:52
Overall execution is skin deep and fails to bring together its many ideas cohesively ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 7:52
Combat is dull and repetitive with weak boss fights serving as flaccid finales ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 8:18

Story & Narrative (5)

Story pacing issues with hours passing between narrative developments making it background noise. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 1:42
Dialogue is a hodgepodge of dialects and styles with anachronisms and odd colloquialisms, not very memorable. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbo @ 1:57
The narrative doesn’t tread any new ground, being predictable despite good worldbuilding. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - S @ 1:03
Setting devolves into predictable tropes and lame anti-twists ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 1:55
Writing and voice acting are inconsistent ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 2:49

Performance & Stability (4)

Das Spiel hat kein Triple-A-Budget, was an einigen Stellen spürbar ist. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 7:22
Loading screens are frequent. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 2:22
Some players criticized the game for an initial malware issue which has since been resolved. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 8:14
Mild technical issues with frame rate drops during long play sessions requiring resets ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review @ 7:15

Controls & User Interface (3)

Controls are not customizable, which could be problematic for players with preferred keybinds. ▶ Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree @ 5:21
The character creator is not the most robust, only getting the job done. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fant @ 1:30
The game does not explain the skill tree system very well initially, which can be overwhelming. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfe @ 2:12

Content & Value (3)

Physical collector's items promised in the Kickstarter have not yet been delivered as of the review date. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review @ 0:54
The price at 40 bucks feels a tad steep; 30 dollars would be more reasonable. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 2:39
The price tag of 40 bucks feels high, though sales may make it more accessible. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 8:33

Sound & Music (3)

Music is a letdown due to poor mixing; even at max volume it feels muffled and barely audible. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Re @ 7:12
The main character's voice acting decreases as the story progresses, reducing their presence in dialogue. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 7:46
Mandragora's voice has some weird mixing issues during the game. ▶ An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree @ 8:28

Graphics & Visuals (1)

Das Mittelalter-Fantasy-Setting punktet weniger mit der Story oder den umfangreichen Dialogen, sondern mehr mit dem Grafikstil. ▶ Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidesc @ 0:40

Review sources

Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree review | PC, PS5, Xbox, Switch 19 pros, 10 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Review - My Fair Review 23 pros, 6 cons
Is Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree a good RPG? 20 pros, 7 cons
I Tried Mandragora and It's... (2025 Gameplay) 24 pros, 1 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Soulsvania Review - Soulsborne Seeker 17 pros, 8 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree got UPDATED! 17 pros, 4 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Average Review 16 pros, 5 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review by IGN — 8 pros, 13 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review - A Near Perfect Soulslike Experience! 13 pros, 7 cons
Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree | Everything You NEED To Know Before Release 19 pros, 0 cons
How To Pick The Best Class For YOU In Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree! (Full Beginner Guide) 13 pros, 5 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree - Test: Starke Sidescroller-Action? 14 pros, 4 cons
An Update on Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree 11 pros, 7 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree is a SAVAGE Dark Fantasy RPG! 15 pros, 2 cons
Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree Critique 7 pros, 6 cons
Mandragora Whispers Of The Witch Tree How To Make The Best Build! 8 pros, 5 cons
Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree | Brutal Gameplay, Deep Buildcrafting 10 pros, 2 cons
Check Out | Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree 8 pros, 3 cons

Frequently asked questions

Is the Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree worth buying?

Based on 18 independent YouTube reviews, the Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree scores 3.9/5 with 262 positive and 95 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #15 in the Indie Games category.

What do reviewers like most about the Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree?

The most praised aspects are gameplay, story & narrative, graphics & visuals — Gameplay (180 mentions), Story & Narrative (19 mentions), Graphics & Visuals (15 mentions).

What are the most common complaints about the Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree?

Reviewers most frequently criticize gameplay, story & narrative — Gameplay (76 mentions), Story & Narrative (5 mentions).

Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!

Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!

☕Buy me a coffee