ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024)
Image source:
RANKING
19
Rank 19 out of 63 Summarized in this category Rankings based on: • Pros-to-cons ratio • Number of reviews • Category average

ASUS

ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024)

around $3699

i
All prices are estimates and may vary from actual prices.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links.

433 Pros

77%
21 reviews (3h 51m)

132 Cons

The ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) is a true desktop replacement, delivering unmatched gaming performance in a (mostly) portable package. Boasting the latest 14th gen Intel i9 processor and up to an RTX 4090 GPU, this laptop crushes even the most demanding AAA titles at max settings. The stunning 18-inch 2.5K mini-LED display with a 240Hz refresh ...

Summary of pros and cons from human reviewers, put together by AI

93%

111 vs 9

Performance

73%

79 vs 29

Design & Build Quality

88%

102 vs 14

Display

76%

26 vs 8

Keyboard & Trackpad

75%

41 vs 14

Connectivity

Reviewer verdict

Across 21 YouTube reviews, the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) earns an Index score of 4.1/5, ranking #19 among Laptops. Reviewers most often praise its performance, display, design & build quality, while the most common criticisms concern design & build quality, value for money.

The ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) is repeatedly praised as a top-tier, performance-focused gaming laptop, with many reviewers (65 mentions) calling it the most powerful or a performance juggernaut thanks to high-end Intel CPUs and NVIDIA RTX 40-series GPUs and effective cooling. Reviewers also consistently highlight the display (55 mentions) — an 18-inch QHD+ 240 Hz / Mini LED Nebula HDR panel with wide color coverage, high peak brightness in HDR and strong color accuracy — as one of the best on the market. Build and thermals earn frequent positive notes (49 mentions) for a redesigned chassis, tri-fan/liquid-metal cooling and generally solid, premium-feeling construction that balances noise and temperatures well. Extras like plentiful connectivity, upgradeable storage/memory and a large, satisfying keyboard and trackpad are commonly noted as additional strengths across reviews.

Criticisms center on the Scar 18’s size, weight and battery limitations, with many reviewers (17 portability mentions, 14 battery mentions) calling it heavy, bulky and better suited as a desktop replacement that requires being plugged in for sustained gaming. Several reviewers (29 design/build mentions) also point out tradeoffs in materials and fan noise — noting substantial plastic in the chassis, fan noise under load and occasional high temperatures during intense use. Price and value are another recurring downside (18 mentions), with multiple reviewers calling the laptop very expensive and noting large price jumps for top GPU or storage options. A smaller set of reviewers raised concerns about display quirks (14 mentions) like HDR nit limitations, minor IPS glow/flicker reports and the webcam/port placement and webcam quality being underwhelming.

Analysis based on 21 YouTube reviews (3h 51m of video) with 433 pros and 132 cons extracted.

Pros (433)

Performance (111)
Display (102)
Design & Build Quality (79)
Connectivity (41)
Keyboard & Trackpad (26)
Storage & Memory (25)
Value for Money (16)
Battery Life (12)
Software & Operating System (11)
Portability (10)

Cons (132)

Design & Build Quality (29)
Value for Money (18)
Portability (17)
Display (14)
Battery Life (14)
Connectivity (14)
Performance (9)
Keyboard & Trackpad (8)
Security Features (7)
Software & Operating System (1)
Storage & Memory (1)

Review sources

Frequently asked questions

Is the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) worth buying?

Based on 21 independent YouTube reviews, the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) scores 4.1/5 with 433 positive and 132 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #19 in the Laptops category.

What do reviewers like most about the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024)?

The most praised aspects are performance, display, design & build quality — Performance (111 mentions), Display (102 mentions), Design & Build Quality (79 mentions).

What are the most common complaints about the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024)?

Reviewers most frequently criticize design & build quality, value for money — Design & Build Quality (29 mentions), Value for Money (18 mentions).

Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!

Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!

☕Buy me a coffee